Philippine Supreme Court Scraps Seafarer Bond Rule in Magna Carta
The Philippine Supreme Court has voided RA 12021's bond requirement on disputed monetary awards, the AKSYON Fund premium scheme and the 10% cap on seafarers' lawyers' fees.

Adjustments
- On November 16 the Philippine Supreme Court struck down Section 59 of RA 12021's bond requirement for disputed awards.
- The court voided a 10% ceiling on lawyers' fees in Section 60 of RA 12021 and Section 4 of RA 10706.
- Sections 4 and 5 of DOLE Department Order No. 247 were declared unconstitutional.
- Maritime education provisions (Sections 75, 76, 78) were upheld against challenges by maritime schools.
- The Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers remains in force except for the voided provisions.
Filipino seafarers can now collect disputed monetary awards without posting bond while an appeal runs, after the Philippine Supreme Court struck down key provisions of Republic Act 12021, the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers.
The ruling, announced Monday, November 16, flows from a decision penned by Associate Justice Maria Filomena Singh at the court's November 11 session. Five consolidated petitions challenged the 2024 law and its implementing rules. The court partially granted them.
What did the court strike down?
Section 59 of RA 12021 made awards covering wages, statutory benefits and undisputed amounts immediately enforceable. The catch: seafarers chasing disputed amounts and damages during a pending appeal or judicial review had to post a bond guaranteeing repayment if the award was later reversed or modified.
The court called that requirement unconstitutional — a violation of the due process and equal protection clauses of the Constitution. The demand placed an unfair financial burden on seafarers, it ruled, and put them at a disadvantage against other workers who face no similar restriction.
The justices conceded the government had legitimate aims: preventing "ambulance chasing" — improper solicitation of legal clients — and protecting the maritime industry from awards that could not be recovered if overturned. Those objectives, the court held, still did not justify loading extra financial burden onto seafarers.
One casualty followed another. The court voided the provision letting the Department of Migrant Workers' AKSYON Fund pay bond premiums, finding the arrangement failed the constitutional test that public funds serve a public purpose.
The sweep extended into the implementing rules. Sections 4 and 5, Rule III of Department of Labor and Employment Department Order No. 247, which operationalized the bond requirement, went down as unconstitutional and void. So did Section 1, Rule XXII of the implementing rules, insofar as it applied the bond to awards from complaints filed on or after the law took effect — the court found that exceeded the law's authority and contradicted Section 94, which preserves rights, privileges and benefits Filipino seafarers already enjoyed.
What happened to the lawyer fee caps?
The court also struck down Section 60 of RA 12021 and Section 4 of RA 10706, the Seafarers Protection Act. Both, it ruled, regulate the practice of law — and that territory belongs exclusively to the judiciary under the Constitution.
The provisions had imposed:
- a 10% ceiling on lawyers' fees;
- mandatory notarized certifications and undertakings;
- rules on how lawyers collect fees from seafarers.
Congress may legislate against abusive legal practices, the court allowed, but regulating lawyers' professional conduct is not its job.
Which challenges failed?
Not everyone won. The Philippine Association of Maritime Institutions Inc. and other maritime schools attacked Sections 75, 76 and 78 of the law, which:
- transfer regulatory authority over maritime education to the Maritime Industry Authority;
- link enrollment to available shipboard training slots;
- prohibit tuition or matriculation fees for shipboard training run by third-party providers.
The justices upheld all three, describing them as reasonable government regulation aimed at maintaining educational standards, ensuring student competency and meeting international maritime requirements — no violation of academic freedom.
The court also blessed the law's legislative path: compliance with the three-reading rule, presentment requirements and the one-title-one-subject rule, plus the president's certification of urgency and the bicameral conference committee's actions.
What did the unions say?
The Federation of Free Workers, one of the petitioners, claimed victory. National president Sonny Matula said: "Sa wakas, may pasya na! Dalawang isyu ang inilapit namin sa Korte Suprema, at sa pareho ay nanaig ang mga marino. Tagumpay ito ng mga manggagawa, lalo na ng marinong umuwing may pinsala at ng pamilyang naghihintay ng pambili ng gamot."
Translation: "Finally, there is a decision! We brought two issues before the Supreme Court, and the seafarers prevailed in both. This is a victory for workers, especially for the seafarer who came home injured and the family waiting for money to buy medicine."
The court made one thing plain: the Magna Carta itself remains valid and enforceable, minus the provisions expressly declared unconstitutional or void. For manning agencies and P&I interests handling Filipino crew claims, the appeal-phase leverage just shifted.
via Google News: Seafarers (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
88 articles
Linked entries
- Philippine Supreme Court strikes down seafarer bond rule
- Philippine Supreme Court strikes bond requirement from Seafarers' Magna Carta
- Philippine Supreme Court strikes bond rule in seafarer Magna Carta
- Philippine Supreme Court Strikes Down Seafarers' Bond Rule in Magna Carta
- Philippine Supreme Court voids seafarer bond rule in Magna Carta