Regulation & Policy

Philippine Supreme Court Strikes Down Seafarers' Bond Rule in Magna Carta

The Philippine Supreme Court has voided Section 59 of RA 12021, which made winning seafarers post a bond while owners appealed. Fee caps and the AKSYON fund mechanism fell too.

SC declares parts of Magna Carta of Seafarers unconstitutional. So what? - Rappler
Exhibit · SC declares parts of Magna Carta of Seafarers unconstitutional. So what? - Rappler — Bergadder / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. Supreme Court voided Section 59 of RA 12021, the seafarers' bond requirement, on due process and equal protection grounds.
  2. The Court struck down 10% contingent fee caps in Section 60 of RA 12021 and Section 4 of RA 10706 as intrusion on its authority over legal practice.
  3. Use of the DMW AKSYON Fund for bond premiums was ruled an unconstitutional public-funds use under Section 29(1), Article VI.
  4. Sections 75, 76 and 78 on MARINA jurisdiction and shipboard training were upheld.
  5. The law, signed by Marcos Jr. in 2024, remains valid and enforceable except for the voided provisions.

The Philippine Supreme Court has struck down the bond requirement in the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, ruling that Section 59 of Republic Act No. 12021 violates due process and equal protection under the 1987 Constitution. The decision, penned by Associate Justice Maria Filomena Singh and issued en banc, partially grants five consolidated petitions filed by labor lawyer Sonny Matula, seafarers, labor organizations and maritime educational institutions.

The law, signed by President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. in 2024, was meant to clarify seafarers' rights — just working conditions, the right to organize, freedom from discrimination. One clause backfired.

What did the bond rule actually do?

Section 59 required seafarers who had won labor disputes to post a bond while their shipowner or manning agency appealed the decision. The bond was meant to secure restitution if the award was later reversed or modified. Petitioners argued the only way a seafarer recovers the money is by winning again — a burden, they said, that lands on sick, injured or unemployed crew.

The Court agreed. It found the rule imposes a financial burden on seafarers seeking to enforce favorable judgments and puts them at a disadvantage "not similarly imposed on other workers." The Court recognized the state's interest in preventing ambulance chasing (lawyers soliciting professional employment) and protecting the industry from unrestituted awards, but held those objectives did not justify the restriction on executing monetary awards.

The Court also voided the authorization to use the Department of Migrant Workers' AKSYON Fund — Agarang Kalinga at Saklolo Para sa mga OFW na Nangangailangan — to pay bond premiums. That mechanism, it said, failed the public-purpose requirement of Section 29(1), Article VI of the Constitution. Sections 4 and 5, Rule III of DOLE Department Order No. 247, Series of 2025, fell with it, insofar as they implemented the bond scheme.

"Great, at last, our petition was resolved by the SC. This is victory for workers especially the seafarers," Matula told Rappler.

"It violates the equal protection clause of the 1987 Constitution because land-based workers do not face this requirement," he said of Section 59.

Which other provisions fell?

The Court struck down Section 60 of RA 12021 and Section 4 of RA 10706, the Seafarers Protection Act. Both regulated lawyer-seafarer contracts and capped contingent legal fees at 10%. That, the Court held, intrudes on the Supreme Court's exclusive power to regulate the practice of law under Section 5(5), Article VIII of the Constitution. Matula had argued the cap "may restrict seafarers' access to competent legal counsel."

Also voided: Section 1, Rule XXII of the law's Implementing Rules and Regulations, which applied Section 59 retroactively to complaints filed after the law took effect. The Court found this contravened Section 94 of the law itself, which preserves rights and benefits seafarers enjoyed before effectivity. Administrative regulations cannot diminish rights the statute expressly preserves.

What survived on maritime education?

The Court upheld Sections 75, 76 and 78, challenged by the Philippine Association of Maritime Institutions, Inc. and other schools on academic-freedom grounds. The provisions:

  • give the Maritime Industry Authority (MARINA) jurisdiction over maritime education;
  • require shipboard training for international maritime degree programs, with MARINA setting duration and applicability;
  • require institutions offering those programs to own training ships, simulators or related technologies, or strike agreements with shipping companies, shipowners or agencies for cadet training.

Academic freedom, the Court said, does not exempt institutions from reasonable regulation. The provisions set minimum standards to ensure education quality, seafarer competency and compliance with international maritime standards. The Court also sustained the ban on charging tuition for shipboard training delivered by third-party providers, calling it a measure against unjustified charges.

Petitioners' attack on the legislative process failed too. Congress complied with the three-reading rule under Article VI, the Court found, and it upheld the President's Certification of Urgency and the Bicameral Conference Committee's authority to reconcile House and Senate versions.

The Magna Carta otherwise remains valid and enforceable. "Although the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers was enacted to advance the welfare of Filipino seafarers, all legislative measures must conform to the Constitution," the ruling said.

via Google News: Seafarers (Source)

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

32 articles

Linked entries

  1. Philippine Supreme Court strikes down seafarer bond rule
  2. Philippine Supreme Court voids seafarer bond rule in Magna Carta
  3. Philippine Supreme Court strikes bond rule in seafarer Magna Carta
  4. 837 Filipino Seafarers Repatriated From Black Sea and Hormuz Hotspots
  5. DMW, ITF and Amosup sign tripartite MOU to protect Filipino seafarers

▼ Next article