Regulation & Policy

Philippine Supreme Court voids seafarer bond rule in Magna Carta

The Supreme Court struck down Section 59’s seafarer bond requirement, practice-law controls and AKSYON premium coverage on 11 November 2026, while upholding key maritime training rules.

Supreme Court Declares Seafarers' Bond Requirement Unconstitutional in Magna Carta - Daily Tribune
Exhibit · Supreme Court Declares Seafarers' Bond Requirement Unconstitutional in Magna Carta - Daily Tribune — papazachariasa / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. 11 November 2026: The Supreme Court en banc voided Section 59’s seafarer bond requirement.
  2. RA 12021 took effect on 11 October 2024 after approval on 23 September 2024.
  3. A 10% legal-fee ceiling and related practice-of-law controls were struck down.
  4. Five consolidated petitions covering seafarers, labor groups and maritime schools were partially granted.
  5. Section 94 preserved pre-implementation seafarer rights, defeating the bond rule in the implementing rules.

By Rebecca Stone

The Philippine Supreme Court struck down the seafarers’ bond requirement in Section 59 of Republic Act (RA) 12021 on 11 November 2026. Sitting en banc (as a full court), the justices declared the requirement unconstitutional. Associate Justice Maria Filomena Singh penned the decision.

The Court found that Section 59 violated constitutional guarantees of due process and equal protection. The bond imposed an additional financial burden on seafarers enforcing favorable labor judgments, placing them at a disadvantage against other workers facing no comparable requirement.

What does the bond ruling change?

Section 59 divided monetary awards into two enforcement tracks:

  • Wages, statutory benefits and undisputed amounts: immediately enforceable.
  • Disputed amounts and damages: enforceable during a pending appeal or judicial review only after the seafarer posted a bond guaranteeing repayment if the award was reversed or modified.

The judgment removes that bond requirement. The Court acknowledged the government’s objective of preventing ambulance chasing and protecting the maritime industry against awards that might not be recovered if overturned. The justices held that those concerns did not justify restricting enforcement of monetary awards.

Which related provisions fell?

The Court also invalidated a provision allowing the Department of Migrant Workers’ Agarang Kalinga at Saklolo Para sa mga overseas Filipino worker (OFW) na Nangangailangan (AKSYON) Fund to cover bond premiums. It found that this use of public funds failed the constitutional requirement that public funds serve a public purpose.

The justices struck down provisions in both the Magna Carta and the Seafarers Protection Act regulating the practice of law. Their targets included:

  • A 10% ceiling on legal fees.
  • Requirements for notarized certifications and undertakings.
  • Rules governing the collection of fees from seafarers.

Congress may legislate against ambulance chasing and abusive practices, the Court said, but regulating lawyers’ professional conduct and the practice of law falls within the Supreme Court’s exclusive constitutional authority.

Which maritime education rules survived?

The Court upheld the maritime education and training provisions and rejected academic-freedom objections. The Philippine Association of Maritime Institutions and other maritime schools challenged the transfer of regulatory authority to the Maritime Industry Authority (MARINA), along with enrollment requirements, shipboard training and related fees.

Associate Justice Singh’s decision stated: “academic freedom does not exempt educational institutions from reasonable government regulation.” The Court said reasonable regulation can maintain educational standards, ensure the competency of Filipino seafarers and meet international maritime requirements.

The surviving measures include:

  • Linking enrollment to available shipboard training opportunities.
  • Prohibiting schools from charging tuition or matriculation fees for shipboard training delivered by third-party providers.

How does the implementing rule change?

Republic Act 12021 received approval on 23 September 2024 and took effect on 11 October 2024. It seeks to codify seafarer rights and obligations, strengthen their protection and align maritime education and training with international standards.

The Court voided an implementing-rules provision that applied the bond to monetary awards arising from complaints filed on or after the law took effect. It found a conflict with Section 94, which preserves the rights, privileges and benefits enjoyed by Filipino seafarers before implementation.

The Court also rejected challenges to the legislative process, finding that Congress complied with the three-reading rule and the presentment requirement. Five consolidated petitions from seafarers, labor organizations and maritime educational institutions produced a partial grant.

The judgment leaves most of the law in force: “The Magna Carta remains valid and enforceable except for provisions expressly declared unconstitutional or void.”

via Google News: Seafarers (Source)

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

31 articles

Linked entries

  1. Philippine Supreme Court strikes down seafarer bond rule
  2. Philippine Supreme Court Strikes Down Seafarers' Bond Rule in Magna Carta
  3. Philippine Supreme Court strikes bond rule in seafarer Magna Carta
  4. 837 Filipino Seafarers Repatriated From Black Sea and Hormuz Hotspots
  5. 4,445 seafarers reveal gaps in MLC 2006 protections

▼ Next article