Philippine Supreme Court strikes bond requirement from Seafarers' Magna Carta
The Philippine Supreme Court voided R.A. 12021 provisions requiring seafarers to post bonds in labor disputes, citing due process; author Rep. Jude Acidre defends the intent behind the law.

Adjustments
- Supreme Court ruled en banc on November 11 that bond and legal-fee provisions of R.A. 12021 violate due process and equal protection.
- The bond requirement placed seafarers at a disadvantage not imposed on other workers, the court said.
- R.A. 12021 originated as HB No. 7325, passed second reading in the House in March 2023.
- Section 51 placed contested disability awards by arbiters such as the NLRC in escrow.
- Congress earlier withdrew the bill from enrollment over jurisdictional concerns before final passage.
The Philippine Supreme Court has struck down provisions of Republic Act No. 12021, the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, that required seafarers to post a bond while labor disputes remain under review. The court ruled the requirements violate due process and the Constitution's equal protection clause.
The decision came during the court's en banc session on November 11, partially granting a consolidated petition challenging the law. A copy of the ruling has yet to be released, but the court announced the affected provisions cover the bond requirement and those regulating lawyers' fees and legal representation.
The court said the bond rule imposed an additional financial burden on seafarers awaiting resolution of their labor disputes and placed them at a "disadvantage not similarly imposed on other workers."
Why were the struck provisions written in?
Tingog Rep. Jude Acidre, one of the authors of the bill that became R.A. 12021, said on Tuesday that lawmakers included the provisions to balance seafarer welfare against the interests of companies involved in labor disputes.
"They were the product of careful deliberation and an effort to strike a balance between protecting the rights and welfare of our seafarers and sustaining the Philippines' competitiveness, reputation for excellence, and attractiveness to international maritime companies," Acidre said in a statement.
He said he accepts the verdict. "As one of the authors of the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, we welcome and thank the Supreme Court for its decision, and fully respect its constitutional interpretation and ruling," he said.
"We also recognize that behind every maritime claim is a seafarer and a family seeking justice, security, and dignity, often during difficult and uncertain times. Their right to fair compensation and meaningful access to justice must always be protected," Acidre added.
He flagged continued risks from what he called "ambulance-chasing and other unscrupulous legal practices" targeting seafarers and their families. "Genuine advocacy should ease the burdens of those seeking justice, not take advantage of their vulnerability," he said.
What was the contested escrow mechanism?
R.A. 12021 originated in the 19th Congress as House Bill No. 7325. Even before the bill passed second reading in March 2023, lawmakers questioned its provisions — particularly Section 51.
That section required monetary awards granted by an arbiter, such as the National Labor Relations Commission, to a seafarer disabled in the course of work to be placed in escrow if the employer contests the award.
Former Gabriela party-list Rep. Arlene Brosas warned the provision would hold disability benefits hostage, forcing seafarers through legal proceedings before receiving money they needed. Former Kabayan party-list Rep. Ron Salo, the measure's plenary sponsor, countered that the disability award would still be paid, with only the disputed amount placed in escrow.
Brosas maintained that even claims exceeding the disability award mattered to seafarers and their families. She supported the bill but opposed some provisions even after the House and Senate ratified the bicameral conference committee report on HB No. 7325 and Senate Bill No. 2221.
Congress eventually withdrew the proposed Magna Carta from enrollment with Malacañang, prompted by a separate issue: jurisdictional concerns involving labor disputes.
Acidre closed with a commitment unchanged by the ruling: "We shall protect our Filipino seafarers, ensure that justice is accessible and fair, and sustain a maritime industry that continues to provide dignified livelihoods and opportunities for Filipino families."
via Google News: Seafarers (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
Market editor covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
65 articles
Linked entries
- Philippine Supreme Court voids Magna Carta bond and fee-cap clauses
- Philippine Supreme Court strikes down seafarer bond rule
- Philippine Supreme Court Strikes Down Seafarers' Bond Rule in Magna Carta
- Acidre Defends Voided Bond Provisions of Filipino Seafarers Law
- Philippine Supreme Court strikes bond rule in seafarer Magna Carta