Seafarers

Philippine Supreme Court voids Magna Carta bond and fee-cap clauses

The Philippine Supreme Court voided the Magna Carta's bond requirement and 10% legal fee cap as unconstitutional, while upholding Sections 75, 76 and 78 in a Nov. 11 en banc ruling.

SC strikes down portions of Magna Carta of seafarers - Inquirer.net
Exhibit · SC strikes down portions of Magna Carta of seafarers - Inquirer.net — papazachariasa / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. The Philippine Supreme Court struck down Sections 59 and 60 of RA 12021 in an en banc session on Nov. 11.
  2. Section 59's bond requirement for pending labor cases violated equal protection, the court said.
  3. Section 60 capped attorneys' fees for seafarers at 10 percent and restricted legal representation.
  4. Sections 75, 76 and 78 were upheld; the full decision is not yet public.
  5. President Marcos signed RA 12021, the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, into law in 2024.

The Philippine Supreme Court has struck down as unconstitutional the provisions of the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers that required workers to post a bond while labor cases were pending and restricted their choice of legal counsel. The en banc ruling, handed down on Nov. 11, partially granted five consolidated petitions filed by seafarers' groups. The full decision has not yet been made public.

The petitions came from labor leader Sonny Matula and from maritime and labor organizations, including the Philippine Association of Maritime Institutions, Inc., Concerned Seafarers of the Philippines (CSP) and the Association of Marine Officers & Ratings Inc.

What did the court strike down?

The court found that Section 59 of Republic Act No. 12021 violated the equal protection clauses of the Constitution. The requirement to post a bond pending resolution of labor disputes, the tribunal said, added a financial burden on seafarers awaiting judgment and subjected them to a "disadvantage not similarly imposed on other workers."

Section 60 was also declared unconstitutional and void. That provision imposed limits on seafarers' legal representation, including a 10-percent ceiling on attorneys' fees in labor claims.

Together, the two rulings remove the two most contested financial and procedural hurdles that seafarers' groups had attacked in the law since its passage.

What survived the challenge?

The court upheld Sections 75, 76 and 78, which the same petitioners had also challenged. It ruled that those provisions do not violate the right to academic freedom under the Charter.

The upshot is a partial win for the unions: the core money clauses are gone, while the education-related sections of the statute stand.

How did the seafarers' groups react?

Xavier Bayoneta, chair of CSP, welcomed the ruling. "It demonstrates the strength of the unity among Filipino seafarers, their families, and the entire nation, that will pave the way for us to achieve victory in our fight for our rights," he said in a statement.

His framing signals that the groups view the decision as one step, not the end, of their campaign over the law's terms.

Background: a law years in the making

President Ferdinand Marcos Jr. signed RA 12021, the Magna Carta of Filipino Seafarers, into law in 2024. The measure had sat on the back burner for years before finally clearing the legislature.

Even before the court challenge, several seafarers' groups had criticized the statute for containing what they called "antiseafarer" provisions. The bond requirement and the fee cap were the most prominent of those, and they are now off the books following the Nov. 11 en banc ruling.

For manning agencies, shipowners employing Filipino crews and the lawyers who run money claims for ratings and officers, the practical effect is procedural: claimants no longer need to front a bond to keep a case alive, and no statutory 10-percent ceiling applies to counsel they choose.

The court's written decision, once released, is expected to set out the full reasoning on equal protection and on the scope of permissible regulation of legal representation for seafarers under Philippine law.

via Google News: Seafarers (Source)

Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Market editor covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

65 articles

Linked entries

  1. Philippine Supreme Court strikes bond requirement from Seafarers' Magna Carta
  2. Philippine Supreme Court strikes down seafarer bond rule
  3. Acidre Defends Voided Bond Provisions of Filipino Seafarers Law
  4. Philippine Supreme Court Strikes Down Seafarers' Bond Rule in Magna Carta
  5. Philippine Supreme Court Scraps Seafarer Bond Rule in Magna Carta

▲ Previous article▼ Next article