Fleet & Shipbuilding

GMB slams CMAL 'folly' warning over Ferguson ferry direct awards

GMB Scotland accuses CMAL of a 'brass neck' over ferry delays as the procurer warns direct awards to Ferguson Marine would be 'folly at worst' and cost more than competitive tenders.

Union fury as CMAL brands ScotGov's Ferguson ferry rescue contracts 'folly' - The Herald
Exhibit · Union fury as CMAL brands ScotGov's Ferguson ferry rescue contracts 'folly' - The Herald — JonKline / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa were ordered in 2015 under a £97m contract; Glen Sannox entered service in 2025, seven years late, and Glen Rosa is still undelivered.
  2. CMAL's board called the proposed direct award 'problematic at best and folly at worst'.
  3. The contested contracts cover two ferries for the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra routes under phase two of the Small Vessel Replacement Programme.
  4. Ministers may convert CMAL into a non-departmental public body to enable direct awards under the Teckal exemption.
  5. Ferguson Marine built a third of the current CalMac fleet, according to GMB Scotland.

Ferguson Marine's biggest union has accused CMAL (Caledonian Maritime Assets Ltd, the state-owned ferry procurer) of pinning the blame for Scotland's ferry fiasco on the Port Glasgow workforce while opposing rescue contracts meant to secure the yard's future.

GMB Scotland said CMAL had a "brass neck" over apportioning blame. It argues the procurer shares responsibility for the troubled construction of Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa, and should be helping the yard win new work rather than questioning its ability to build more ships.

The row follows CMAL's warning to Scottish ministers that handing Ferguson Marine two new ferry-building contracts without competitive tendering could cost substantially more than inviting bids from experienced shipbuilders in Britain and overseas.

Robert Deavy, GMB Scotland senior organiser, said: "No shipyard in the world could have built the ferries commissioned by CMAL on time and on budget and it takes a brass neck to suggest the blame is Ferguson alone."

What went wrong with the original order?

Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa were ordered in 2015 under a £97m contract, with delivery due in early to mid-2018. Construction and design problems hit the project, the original shipyard went into administration in 2019, and the Scottish Government took Ferguson Marine into public ownership to protect jobs and finish the vessels.

Glen Sannox finally entered service in 2025, seven years late, while Glen Rosa remains undelivered. Costs have risen well above the original contract price, making it one of the most controversial episodes in Scottish ferry procurement.

The union claims CMAL was complicit in commissioning two large ferries to be built simultaneously at a yard that wasn't properly equipped, with designs that were unfinished and untested.

Deavy said: "CMAL should stop attempting to rewrite history and start helping build a new future for the yard."

Why does CMAL call the direct award 'folly'?

CMAL warned the government that the anticipated cost of designing, fabricating and delivering two new vessels under a direct award "is likely to far outweigh the costs that could be achieved through an open, competitive procurement inviting bids from a range of capable and experienced shipbuilders in the market, both domestic and international, including from a range of different locations such as Turkey, Romania, Poland, and elsewhere".

It also told MSPs: "We cannot escape the risk of additional delays occurring once the project is underway at Ferguson's, such as we have experienced in the completion of Glen Sannox and the still pending delivery of Glen Rosa."

The board added that it "may reasonably consider that the proposed direct award is problematic at best and folly at worst".

CMAL chief executive Kevin Hobbs told Holyrood the organisation did not believe Ferguson Marine was the right place to build the next generation of smaller ferries. He said CMAL had no objection to the government's ambition to retain the last commercial shipyard on the Clyde, but the board had serious concerns about the yard's cost and delivery record.

"We have witnessed that the current vessels that they're building have not been either value for money, and they have been heavily delayed, and we would not want that to happen to the small vessel replacement program," Hobbs said. "Commercially, I do not believe, and we do not believe as a board that we ought to be building ferries there at this point in time because we need them at pace, and we need them to be value for money."

What are the proposed contracts and the Teckal route?

The contested contracts cover two ferries under phase two of the Small Vessel Replacement Programme, intended for the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra routes. Ministers have also announced two further vessels for Marine Scotland under a wider programme designed to give Ferguson Marine new work.

Ministers are considering changing CMAL's status from a public corporation to a non-departmental public body, which could let it meet legal requirements for a direct award under the Teckal exemption (an EU-derived mechanism that bypasses state aid rules for in-house awards).

Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn defended building in Scotland, saying: "the choice to build in Scotland is inescapably a political decision. I believe it is the right political decision".

GMB Scotland also criticised CMAL's earlier procurement decisions, claiming conditions imposed on previous contracts couldn't have been met by Ferguson Marine or any other UK yard.

"No other country has been so keen to send public money abroad to shipyards receiving far more effective government support because of their industrial and economic importance," Deavy said. He also questioned why the legal groundwork for direct awards hadn't started earlier, arguing CMAL was "rushing to buy ferries from abroad instead of exploring how it might support good jobs and apprenticeships in Scotland".

He noted Ferguson Marine built a third of the current CalMac fleet and was once Scotland's ferry factory. "If the current leadership of CMAL cannot imagine a successful future for a yard with such a long history of delivering for our island communities then the problem is with the current leadership of CMAL not the shipbuilders of Ferguson Marine," he said.

via Google News: Shipbuilding (Source)

Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Market editor covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

65 articles

Linked entries

  1. Cmal warns direct ferry award to Ferguson Marine would be 'folly at worst'
  2. CMAL warns it would be 'folly' to give Ferguson Marine new ferry contracts
  3. CMAL chief rejects Ferguson Marine direct award for two small ferries
  4. CMAL takes delivery of Loch Indaal, 20 months late
  5. Belfast shipyard positioned for billions in UK defence contracts

▲ Previous article▼ Next article