Cmal warns direct ferry award to Ferguson Marine would be 'folly at worst'
Cmal has told ministers a direct ferry award to Ferguson Marine would be 'problematic at best and folly at worst', citing cost, delay and quality fears as Glen Rosa nears nine years late.

Adjustments
- Cmal warned a direct ferry award to Ferguson Marine would be 'problematic at best and folly at worst'
- Glen Rosa will approach nine years late if it hits its February delivery deadline
- Ferguson Marine lost an initial order of seven electric ferries to a Polish yard last year
- It has been ten years since the yard delivered Catriona, its last small hybrid-electric vessel
- Ministers are seeking competition-authority advice on directly awarding Barra and Harris ferry contracts
Scotland's vessel-owning agency has told ministers, in writing, that handing Ferguson Marine new ferry contracts without competition would be "problematic at best and folly at worst". Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited (Cmal) set out the verdict in a letter from chief executive Kevin Hobbs and chair Morag McNeill, revealed at the Scottish Parliament's transport committee on Wednesday.
Willie Rennie, the committee's convener, said he had "never seen such a strong letter". That's the measure of it. Cmal's own buyer now doubts the yard it is supposed to work with.
Why does Cmal oppose a direct award?
Three reasons, all blunt. Cost, delay and quality.
On value for money, the letter states: "the anticipated cost to design, fabricate and deliver the vessels at Fergusons under a directly awarded contract is likely to far outweigh the costs that could be achieved through an open competitive procurement inviting bids from a range of capable and experienced shipbuilders in the market both domestic and international."
Committee member Graham Simpson read that passage into the record himself, which tells you how seriously MSPs took it.
On schedule risk, Cmal sees two problems. First, a comparative delay: Ferguson's design-and-build phases will run longer than those of "a first class shipyard with a recent proven track in production of vessels of this type". Second, the risk of slippage mid-project, "such as we have experienced in the completion of Glen Sannox and the still pending delivery of Glen Rosa".
Glen Rosa is the yard's unfinished job. The Port Glasgow vessel will approach nine years late if it hits its latest delivery deadline of February, having already missed a series of earlier dates.
On quality, the letter notes it has been ten years since Catriona entered service — the last small hybrid-electric vessel the yard completed. Cmal wrote that given the yard's well-documented struggles since nationalisation, "there is nervousness as to the capability to produce high-quality vessels at pace".
The board's bottom line was unsparing: "the detriment to the island communities of a direct award to [Ferguson Marine] far outweighs the planned benefit to the workforce of Inverclyde." Cmal added it was "difficult to see why a decision to build ferries would be made" — and suggested building "other vessels at that facility but certainly not the ferries that are desperately needed to support the island economies".
What is the government doing?
Ministers want competition-authority advice on whether they can legally steer contracts for electric ferries for Barra and Harris to the Scottish Government-owned yard. Ferguson Marine lost out last year to a Polish yard for an initial order of seven similar vessels.
Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn defended the jobs-first approach. He said: "I believe it is the right political decision, not just for the islanders who will be able to be in receipt of new vessels, but also for the workforce in Scotland's last remaining shipyard on the Clyde."
Flynn argued Ferguson Marine "have a very strong record in relation to delivering these sorts of vessels in the past and I look forward to them being able to deliver these types of vessels again in the future by utilising the workforce at Inverclyde who deserve our support."
That record, though, is the problem. Cmal's Hobbs had previously expressed "absolute" confidence in the yard's ability to build small ferries, based on several completed a decade ago. The new letter marks a significant shift in that position.
How has the yard responded?
Yard chief executive Graeme Thomson said Ferguson Marine had "learned hard lessons" from Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa. "Ferguson Marine has new leadership, stronger governance, greater programme management control and a skilled workforce ready to deliver," he said. "Our recent past does not define our future and our focus remains on showing that our yard can and will build Scotland's ferries well, on time and to budget."
Every promise there is a future promise. Glen Rosa hasn't delivered yet.
GMB Scotland, the main union at the yard, went further and accused Cmal of not wanting to place orders there at all. Senior organiser Robert Deavy pointed to the previous electric-ferries order going abroad, and to conditions imposed that stopped the yard bidding to replace the larger CalMac ferry Lord of the Isles.
"People have short memories but Fergusons built a third of the current CalMac fleet and was once, not that long ago, Scotland's ferry factory," Deavy said. "With the right leadership and proper investment, it can again deliver a steady stream of first-class small ferries for Scotland's islanders. The lack of ambition and support for a publicly-owned shipyard with such strategic industrial potential is beyond grim."
So the standoff is set: the buyer says competition wins on cost, schedule and quality; the government wants Clyde shipbuilding kept alive; the union wants the orders back home. The Barra and Harris vessels, needed by island economies, sit in the middle. The competition-authority advice on a legal direct award is the next move — and until Glen Rosa actually delivers, every assurance from Port Glasgow rests on a yard still proving it can finish what it starts.
via Google News: Shipbuilding (Source)
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
30 articles
Linked entries
- CMAL chief rejects Ferguson Marine direct award for two small ferries
- CMAL takes delivery of Loch Indaal, 20 months late
- Norwegian Yards Locked Out of Navy Tender Take Case to Parliament
- Steer acquires Mercator consultancy in fourth deal since 2021
- Nine Shipping Trade Bodies Tell IMO: Fix the Net-Zero Split