CMAL chief rejects Ferguson Marine direct award for two small ferries
CMAL chief Kevin Hobbs opposes giving Ferguson Marine two small electric ferries, citing delay, cost and LNG risks, while Scottish ministers remain committed to direct awards.

Adjustments
- CMAL chief executive Kevin Hobbs was 100% opposed to a direct award of two small ferries to nationalised Ferguson Marine.
- The second phase covers two, possibly three, small electric ferries for the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra.
- CMAL has not awarded a shipbuilding contract to a UK yard since 2015; phase one's seven ferries went to Gdansk's Remontowa last year.
- Ferguson entered administration in 2019 and was later nationalised; major cost increases occurred from 2022 to 2024.
- Glen Sannox has not used LNG since a faulty engine valve caused an unexpected leak in July 2025.
By Sophie Lindqvist
What is CMAL opposing?
CMAL chief executive Kevin Hobbs, head of Scotland's state-owned ferries procurement agency, told MSPs he was 100% opposed to awarding two small ferries directly to nationalised Ferguson Marine. His position puts CMAL's board against a March pledge from SNP ministers to give the Port Glasgow yard new work.
The second phase of the Small Vessels Replacement Programme covers two, possibly three, small electric ferries for the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra. Preliminary work has finished, but ministers have held the procurement while they consider a direct award.
Hobbs said a direct award is not currently lawful, although planned changes to CMAL's governance structure could permit one next year. Scotland's ministers, CMAL's sole shareholder, would need to instruct the agency and its board, both of which oppose the move.
Why does CMAL reject a direct award?
Hobbs said: “While we want to see that shipyard survive, we do not believe building ferries there is the right thing to do for the island communities.” Ferguson Marine sits a few minutes' walk from CMAL's Port Glasgow offices, and Hobbs wants the near-neighbour yard to survive. He sees no commercial case for another award at present.
He warned that the delays, overspending and poor value for money associated with MV Glen Sannox and MV Glen Rosa could recur on the small-ferry programme. In a public letter to Transport Scotland, Hobbs called a direct award problematic at best and folly at worst. He said building in Scotland would be political rather than a procurement choice.
CMAL wants an open tender involving international bidders. It has not awarded a shipbuilding contract to any Scottish or UK yard since 2015, instead placing numerous orders with companies in Turkey, Poland and China.
The first phase comprised seven small ferries and went last year to Gdansk-based Remontowa, whose price undercut Ferguson Marine despite CMAL's praise for the Scottish yard's build quality. UK builders say overseas yards benefit from cheaper labour and stronger state support, and argue that public procurement should recognise those wider domestic benefits.
Why does the government still back Ferguson?
Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn told the same Holyrood transport committee that the Scottish government remains committed to direct awards. He described Ferguson's River Clyde yard as the area's last surviving commercial shipyard. He said he was extremely confident in its delivery ability and that direct work would protect island-service resilience.
The then transport secretary Fiona Hyslop announced the small-vessel plan in March, weeks before the Holyrood election. Former economy secretary Kate Forbes also disclosed direct-award proposals for two further vessels, a marine protection ship and a research vessel, each subject to due diligence.
She said the work would benefit island and Inverclyde communities and support Ferguson's recovery. The announcements covered two small ferries and two additional vessels, subject to the required due diligence.
Ferguson Marine chief executive Graeme Thomson said the yard had learned hard lessons from Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa. Glen Sannox is now in service, with Glen Rosa due to follow shortly.
Thomson put the yard's position this way: “Our recent past does not define our future and our focus remains on showing that our yard can and will build Scotland's ferries well, on time and to budget.” He cited new leadership, stronger governance, greater programme-management control and a skilled workforce ready to deliver.
Thomson also highlighted skilled employment in Port Glasgow, the survival of Clyde shipbuilding skills and Ferguson's proud shipbuilding record. He said that history stretches back much further than the yard's recent difficulties.
Ferguson previously built three small hybrid-power ferries for CalMac, and all remain in service. Their design resembles the small vessels now under procurement.
GMB stewards Alex Logan and Kenny Meechan said they were shocked and extremely disappointed by Hobbs's comments. Regional organiser Robert Deavy said CMAL shared responsibility for the two contracts and should support the blameless workforce.
He noted that people have short memories, Ferguson built one-third of CalMac's current fleet and once served as Scotland's ferry factory. With proper leadership and investment, the yard could again deliver a steady stream of first-class small ferries.
What risk does LNG pose?
CMAL remains under pressure over its role in the earlier vessels, including its alleged influence over the liquefied natural gas (LNG) dual-fuel propulsion system, which complicated construction. CMAL was believed to have driven that propulsion choice.
Former Ferguson owners said the tender lacked enough preliminary work to prove the specifications feasible. CMAL denied that claim, blamed poor management decisions at the yard and rejected requests for additional cost.
CalMac chief executive Duncan Mackison and Hobbs conceded that Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa might never run on gas again. Glen Sannox stopped using LNG after a faulty engine valve caused an unexpected leak in July 2025.
Its current deployment prevents gas refuelling. Hobbs called LNG hugely expensive and said no commercial operator would choose gas while diesel offered a much cheaper operating option.
Mackison also questioned whether investment in new LNG refuelling facilities could be justified. The dispute over specifications, management and extra costs drove Ferguson into administration in 2019; the yard was later nationalised while design issues, delays and cost increases continued.
Significant progress occurred from 2022 to 2024. During the same period, some of the largest cost increases occurred while CMAL had seconded an employee to Ferguson Marine to oversee completion of the two ferries.
via Google News: Shipbuilding (Source)
More from Sophie Lindqvist
Show full bio
Market editor covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
31 articles
Linked entries
- Cmal warns direct ferry award to Ferguson Marine would be 'folly at worst'
- CMAL takes delivery of Loch Indaal, 20 months late
- Steer acquires Mercator consultancy in fourth deal since 2021
- Nigeria urges IMO action on maritime security and seafarer safety
- Nine shipping bodies tell IMO: end the stalemate, give us one global rule