Norwegian Yards Locked Out of Navy Tender Take Case to Parliament
FMA's November 4 rules require NOK1 billion equity, shutting out all 22 Norwegian yards; Norske Skipsverft asks the Storting to rewrite terms for 28 naval and Coast Guard vessels.

Adjustments
- FMA issued qualification requirements on November 4 that exclude all 22 Norwegian-owned yards from a tender for up to 28 vessels.
- The NOK1 billion ($103 million) equity requirement exceeds the combined equity of Norway's three largest yards.
- Consortium members face joint and several liability of 21 to nearly 270 times their own equity.
- Two contracts cover up to 14 naval vessels and six Coast Guard vessels of a 90-metre ocean-going design.
- Norske Skipsverft demands at least 80 per cent of working hours performed in Norway.
Qualification rules published on November 4 by Forsvarsmateriell (FMA, Norway's defence procurement agency) exclude every Norwegian-owned shipyard from the tender for up to 28 standardised vessels for the Royal Norwegian Navy and Coast Guard, according to shipbuilders' association Norske Skipsverft. The association, representing 22 yards, has now asked the Storting, Norway's parliament, to intervene directly in the procurement.
The numbers behind the exclusion are stark. Even the three largest Norwegian-owned yards, acting together, fall short of the NOK1 billion ($103 million) equity requirement set for the naval contract, the association said in its letter to parliament.
The liability structure compounds the problem. Each yard joining a consortium would carry joint and several liability for the entire contract — an exposure equal to between 21 and nearly 270 times its own equity, depending on the yard.
What is Norske Skipsverft demanding?
The association has set out four specific asks to the Storting:
- Revised financial requirements that would let Norwegian yards compete individually or together
- A fairer sharing of construction risk between the state and the yards
- A guarantee that at least 80 per cent of working hours take place in Norway
- All cable pulling and termination work carried out at Norwegian yards
The ownership and geography requirements, or rather their absence, sit at the centre of the dispute. The association objected that the tender documents permit the entire hull to be built abroad, with no requirement for Norwegian ownership of the builder and no requirement that construction take place in a NATO country.
What does the current competition cover?
The competition now under way covers the 90-metre ocean-going variant of the standardised vessel design, split across two planned contracts: one for up to 14 naval vessels and one for six Coast Guard vessels. FMA has said the two-contract structure is intended to allow broad participation by Norwegian suppliers.
The risk allocation draws the sharpest criticism from the yards. Managing director Asle B. Strønen said: "The yards must take overall responsibility at a fixed price, including for designs and systems FMA itself has selected, and suppliers have no right of appeal. Taken together, this is very serious."
Under the current terms, a yard would bear fixed-price responsibility for design and system choices made by the procurement agency itself, while suppliers left aggrieved by the process would have no avenue of appeal.
Is there common ground among the yards?
Not entirely. Norwegian yards have also disagreed among themselves over whether domestic hull-building capacity exists at the scale the programme would demand, a split that complicates the association's call for parliament to force workshare back onshore.
With the Storting now in receipt of the letter, the ball sits with legislators: revise the qualification thresholds and risk allocation, or watch a fleet renewal programme worth billions of kroner go to foreign hulls.
via Google News: Shipbuilding (Source)
More from Rebecca Stone
Show full bio
News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
31 articles
Linked entries
- India weighs SEZ status for five greenfield shipbuilding clusters
- Boskalis-Van Oord-Rohde Nielsen JV wins Gothenburg fairway deepening
- Cmal warns direct ferry award to Ferguson Marine would be 'folly at worst'
- COSL books 59 OSVs at Fujian yards for US$1.6Bn
- COSL orders 59 offshore support vessels in $1.64bn deal