CMAL warns it would be 'folly' to give Ferguson Marine new ferry contracts
CMAL has told MSPs that awarding Ferguson Marine new ferry contracts would be 'folly at worst', citing 'fundamental concerns' over value for money, delays and quality at the state-owned Clyde yard.

Adjustments
- CMAL told MSPs a direct ferry award to Ferguson Marine would be 'folly at worst' and 'problematic at best'
- CMAL cited 'fundamental concerns' over value for money, delays and quality at the Scottish government-owned yard
- Four years ago CMAL chief executive Kevin Hobbs said he would 'absolutely' entrust small vessels to the yard
- GMB Scotland notes Ferguson's built a third of the current CalMac fleet
- Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn said maintaining Clyde shipbuilding was 'the right political decision'
Caledonian Maritime Assets Limited has told MSPs it would be "folly at worst" to award Ferguson Marine new ferry contracts, and "problematic at best", citing "fundamental concerns" over value for money, delays and quality at the Scottish government-owned yard on the Clyde.
The letter, from the government quango that procures CalMac's vessels, lands at a delicate moment. The Port Glasgow shipyard is still struggling to finish two long-delayed and over-budget ferries for CalMac, and the fight over who owns that calamity has now turned into open warfare between the yard's owner — the Scottish Government — and its own procurement arm.
CMAL's board did not mince words. "The Cmal board feels strongly that the detriment to the island communities of a direct award to [Ferguson Marine] far outweighs the planned benefit to the workforce of Inverclyde," the letter reads. And on the yard's track record: "We understand the desire to retain jobs in the area but a combination of past performance in terms of time and costs it is difficult to see why a decision to build ferries would be made."
That is procurement-speak for: don't.
What does this mean for the yard?
Willie Rennie MSP said he had "never seen such a strong letter" from CMAL — and he has read a few. The intervention could potentially sound the yard's death knell, coming as it does from the very body that would have to place any future orders.
The irony is hard to miss. Four years ago, when the problems with the two-ferry programme were already evident, CMAL expressed full confidence in Ferguson's capabilities. Chief executive Kevin Hobbs said at the time: "Would we entrust small vessels to be built at that yard? Absolutely we would."
The yard's defenders have long memories of a different kind. Robert Deavy of the GMB Scotland union bemoaned what he called people's "short memories". "Ferguson's built a third of the current CalMac fleet and was once, not that long ago, Scotland's ferry factory," Deavy said. "With the right leadership and proper investment, it can again deliver a steady stream of first-class small ferries for Scotland's islanders."
A third of the fleet is not nothing. But heritage does not deliver hulls on schedule, and CMAL's letter makes clear the buyer no longer trusts the builder to do either.
Where does the Scottish Government stand?
Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn suggested the government would stand by the yard, arguing that maintaining commercial shipbuilding on the Clyde was "the right political decision, not just for the islanders... but also for the workforce".
That position carries an awkward corollary. If the yard is not to blame for the mess, then responsibility shifts to those who specified, funded and oversaw the work — CMAL and the Scottish Government themselves. Flynn's defence of the yard tacitly concedes there is merit in the case made by those who have pointed fingers at both.
So the government finds itself in the unenviable position of owning a shipyard that its own ferry-buying quango refuses to recommend for new orders, while insisting shipbuilding on the Clyde must continue.
For now, the losers in the blame game look to be the island communities still waiting for their ferries, and a workforce in Inverclyde whose futures depend on contracts CMAL says nobody sensible would place. The letter is on the record. So is the vote of confidence from four years ago.
Somebody in Edinburgh will have to pick a side.
via Google News: Shipbuilding (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
63 articles
Linked entries
- Cmal warns direct ferry award to Ferguson Marine would be 'folly at worst'
- CMAL takes delivery of Loch Indaal, 20 months late
- CMAL chief rejects Ferguson Marine direct award for two small ferries
- Belfast shipyard positioned for billions in UK defence contracts
- Steer acquires Mercator consultancy in fourth deal since 2021