Another IMO delay would make uncertainty the policy, Lloyd's List warns
Over 50 states back NZF-style proposals versus about 22 for the 'Fundamental Redesign', yet MEPC85 delay risk is growing — and a second postponement would hit investment harder than the first.

Adjustments
- More than 50 states backed NZF-like proposals at MEPC84, against about 22 for the 'Fundamental Redesign'
- UCL's Tristan Smith said 14 months of effort has failed to identify a superior architecture to the NZF
- IMO market-based-measure talks stalled in 2013 and were not seriously reopened until 2021
- The EU's ETS and FuelEU Maritime are already live; Djibouti and Gabon have introduced carbon pricing for international shipping
- A protracted MEPC85 delay could mean waiting two years or more for political realignment
More than 50 states backed Net-Zero Framework-style proposals at MEPC84 against roughly 22 for the "Fundamental Redesign" — yet the most dangerous assumption around MEPC85, according to Lloyd's List Editor-in-Chief Richard Meade, is that another delay would simply preserve the status quo.
It would not. Shipping does not get a regulatory vacuum if the IMO fails to agree. It gets the energy transition anyway, Meade argues in the latest Daily View briefing — only with less certainty, more regional regulation and potentially a much more disorderly adjustment later.
A year supposedly spent finding political compromise has not fundamentally shifted the argument. UCL's assessment is that NZF-like proposals still command substantially greater support than the alternatives, and proposals without a meaningful economic element face both political and procedural obstacles.
Tristan Smith, professor of energy and transport at the UCL Energy Institute, put it plainly during this week's Lloyd's List webinar: 14 months of effort has failed to identify a superior architecture. The choice increasingly looks binary — a surgically modified NZF, or a protracted delay driven less by policy design than by geopolitics.
How long could a delay actually run?
That could mean waiting two years or more for political realignment. History offers little comfort. When IMO market-based-measure talks stalled in 2013, they were not seriously reopened until 2021 — an eight-year gap that nobody financing a newbuilding today should ignore.
Meanwhile, investment decisions cannot wait.
The warning lights are already flashing. Recent Lloyd's List reporting shows appetite for first-mover green investment is visibly waning, and green ambition is being scaled back daily. Voluntary leadership can prepare a market, but it cannot create the global business case required to scale it.
And delay does not remove transition risk. UCL's new modelling makes precisely the opposite point. Owners remain exposed to changing cargo demand and eventually to regulation of ships' own emissions. The difference is whether they receive a predictable timetable against which to manage those risks.
Would failure at MEPC85 mean less regulation?
No — quite the reverse. Failure at MEPC85 would strengthen the case for regional intervention, and the building blocks are already in place:
- The EU already has its ETS and FuelEU Maritime regime in force.
- Djibouti and Gabon have introduced carbon pricing for international shipping.
- Other African states are considering similar measures.
The result is not less regulation. It is potentially overlapping carbon costs, incompatible compliance systems and escalating administrative complexity — a compliance officer's least favourite cocktail, served at fleet level.
Why the second delay bites harder than the first
Another delay would be more damaging than the first, Meade writes, because every year lost compresses the path to 2050. That weakens investment today while making the eventual transition steeper.
The arithmetic is unforgiving. Squeeze the same decarbonisation effort into a shorter window and the annual capital calls rise, the technology options narrow, and the shipping lines that waited for clarity find the clarity arrived bundled with a bill.
MEPC85 therefore needs to be judged against a deceptively simple test: does its outcome give companies a credible reason to invest?
If not, uncertainty will no longer be an unfortunate by-product of the IMO process. It will effectively have become the policy.
via Google News: IMO Regulation (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
88 articles
Linked entries
- IMarEST backs IMO Net-Zero Framework after 60 policy tests
- Industry Backs IMO Net Zero Deal Publicly While Lobbying to Weaken It
- IMO members urged to adopt Net-Zero Framework by year-end
- Clean Shipping Coalition Pushes for Net-Zero Framework Adoption at MEPC 85
- EU ETS likely to survive any IMO zero-carbon deal, IBIA panel says