Regulation & Policy

EU ETS likely to survive any IMO zero-carbon deal, IBIA panel says

IBIA delegates in New York expect shipping to adapt to any IMO Net-Zero Framework outcome, while the EU ETS persists and New York alternative-fuel calls may rise from four to 45.

IBIA 2026: Don't Expect Agreement on IMO NZF to Spell End of EU ETS - Ship & Bunker
Exhibit · IBIA 2026: Don't Expect Agreement on IMO NZF to Spell End of EU ETS - Ship & Bunker — dendoktoor / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. $200 billion has gone into dual-fuel newbuild orders, most starting with LNG.
  2. EU ETS and FuelEU Maritime already operate, and the EU is unlikely to relinquish ETS revenue despite any IMO deal.
  3. Only 4 of about 6,000 annual New York and New Jersey deep-draft calls could burn alternative fuel in 2024; 45 are expected by end-2026.
  4. Shipping emissions fell about 20% from 2008, then rose about 20% in recent years.
  5. IMO new-fuel safety rules are not expected before 2028; hydrogen rules are not expected before 2032.

By Rebecca Stone

About $200 billion has already gone into dual-fuel newbuild orders, most starting with LNG (liquefied natural gas), an IBIA panel said in New York.

Delegates said shipping could fund an alternative-fuel transition if a strong framework created a clear demand signal. The unresolved variable is the rulebook: whatever emerges from current talks on the IMO's Net-Zero Framework (NZF), the industry will adapt.

The Regional & Global Maritime Associations Panel at last week’s IBIA 2026 Annual Convention heard that argument under the Chatham House rule. Alexander Prokopakis, Executive Director of IBIA, moderated a discussion featuring:

  • Bo Cerup-Simonsen, CEO of the Mærsk Mc-Kinney Møller Center for Zero Carbon Shipping
  • Peter Keller, Chairman of SEA-LNG
  • Joe Kramek, President & CEO of the World Shipping Council
  • Carleen Lyden Walker, Co-Founder & CEO of NAMEPA
  • Bethann Rooney, Director, Port Department, Port Authority of New York and New Jersey

What does an IMO agreement change?

The panel said the industry needs a global standard. Consensus on a workable IMO framework could trigger the long-awaited investment wave in alternative-fuel ships and associated port infrastructure after a period of regulatory limbo. Its operating logic links rules, tools and fuels: IMO rules create demand, dual-fuel ships provide the tool, and ports must supply the appropriate fuel.

  • Demand signal: The industry is able and willing to invest, and can afford to do so, if a strong regulatory framework sets absolute targets and sends a clear demand signal.
  • Cost test: Shipping a pair of sneakers costs about seven cents; the carbon framework would add one penny.
  • Emissions trend: Shipping's total emissions fell about 20% from 2008, but rose about 20% in recent years as bottlenecks pushed up ton-miles (the distance a ton of cargo is carried).
  • Milestones: The 2030 targets look hard to reach, making 2035 and 2040 more useful milestones for discussion.

Will the EU ETS disappear after a global deal?

Regional schemes have already started, including the EU Emissions Trading System (EU ETS) and FuelEU Maritime. Even if the IMO reaches a deal, the panel expects the regulatory patchwork to remain because the EU is unlikely to give up the ETS.

EU politicians said they would consider adjustments based on IMO steps. But ETS revenue goes to member states, making it very difficult to claw back. Peter Keller, Chairman of SEA-LNG, put the fiscal logic bluntly: "What government do we know anywhere in the world is prepared to give up tax revenue?"

The UK and Turkey are also looking at their own measures, and the panel cited an African carbon coalition. For an average shipowner with six to 10 ships, EU ETS administration is already exceedingly complex. The patchwork could add significant complexity and cost for global operators.

Can New York close its alternative-fuel gap?

About 6,000 deep-draft vessels call at New York and New Jersey each year. Only four could burn an alternative fuel in 2024, but that total is expected to reach 45 by the end of this year. None can lift alternative fuel in New York because rules in both states prevent vessel-to-vessel transfers of LNG.

Alternative-fuel bunkering in New York faces a supply-demand mismatch: suppliers are willing to serve, but demand remains insufficient to justify investment. The Port Authority of New York and New Jersey would consider hosting bunkering facilities if container lines named one or two fuels they plan to standardise on.

The boards of Los Angeles and Long Beach will begin working with CARB (California Air Resources Board) on bringing alternative fuels to those ports. LNG bunkers there currently arrive by bunker vessel from Vancouver.

Truck-to-ship skids linking four trailers can deliver 25 trailer loads in five or six hours, so some bunkering can start without major investment. Community safety concerns about new fuels must be addressed in parallel with, or ahead of, international regulation.

Which fuels will ships carry profitably?

Shipping will use a basket of fuels shaped by safety, availability, affordability, scalability and energy density. The last measure will be decisive, the panel said, asking: "Do shipowners want to carry fuel, or do they want to carry revenue?"

LNG is doing well thanks to its supply chains, pricing and availability at most major ports.

When will safety rules and crews catch up?

IMO safety regulations for new fuels are not expected before 2028, and rules for hydrogen not before 2032. The hardest part of crew training is obtaining sea time because few new-fuel ships remain in service. Crews on new-fuel vessels, including ammonia-fuelled ships, say they are comfortable operating them with proper training and ship design.

An IMO agreement would supply a global demand signal, not end regional compliance.

via Google News: IMO Regulation (Source)

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

31 articles

Linked entries

  1. IMO members urged to adopt Net-Zero Framework by year-end
  2. Clean Shipping Coalition Tells IMO: Adopt Net-Zero Framework As Is
  3. Nine Shipping Bodies Push for IMO Net-Zero Deal as Rules Split Industry
  4. IMO Reopens Net-Zero Framework Talks November 30
  5. Nine Shipping Trade Bodies Tell IMO: Fix the Net-Zero Split

▲ Previous article