Regulation & Policy

IMarEST backs IMO Net-Zero Framework after 60 policy tests

IMarEST modelled 60 policy combinations and still recommends the IMO Net-Zero Framework as drafted, urging reward mechanisms for zero-emission fuels and predictable regulation at MEPC 85.

Shipping Decarbonisation: IMarEST Calls for Regulatory Certainty and Investment Clarity Ahead of MEPC 85
Exhibit · Shipping Decarbonisation: IMarEST Calls for Regulatory Certainty and Investment Clarity Ahead of MEPC 85 — hunt-er / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. IMarEST submitted three assessments to IMO member states ahead of MEPC 85
  2. First analysis models 60 policy combinations and still recommends the Net-Zero Framework in its original form
  3. Second analysis finds well-designed reward mechanisms best support scalable zero-emission fuels and developing economies
  4. Third submission covers regulatory predictability as GHG fuel intensity limits tighten over time
  5. Alasdair Wishart: policy certainty is the precondition for industry investment at scale

IMarEST tested 60 policy combinations on shipping decarbonisation and still backs the IMO's Net-Zero Framework as drafted. The Institute of Marine Engineering, Science and Technology put three assessments to IMO member states ahead of MEPC 85, and its verdict on the framework as written is a qualified yes.

What did IMarEST put to MEPC 85?

Three assessments. One examines the economic impact of the proposed Net-Zero Framework. A second weighs the effectiveness of incentives for zero-emission fuels. The third sets out options for long-term regulatory predictability.

All three went to member states, which take the decisions. The Institute supplies evidence and does not vote.

The delegation's head is Tristan Smith, Professor of Energy and Transport at UCL's Energy Institute. Smith said: "It is crucial to have a clear picture of the environmental, commercial, and economic consequences of the Net Zero Framework, and any modifications to it. Ahead of MEPC 85, the IMarEST delegation has submitted three analyses to help member states assess the options on the table."

Does the framework survive 60 combinations?

The first analysis models 60 different policy combinations. Its conclusion: the Net-Zero Framework in its original form remains the recommended decarbonisation solution, because it balances cost-effectiveness against the economic impacts on states.

That is the promise. The caveat sits in the modelling, because the release publishes no cost per tonne, no fuel price assumption, no sensitivity range and no ranking of the 60 options.

A recommendation drawn from 60 modelled pathways is not a measurement of what a shipowner actually pays, and a silent comparison table is a thin basis for a capital decision.

Are rewards the answer for developing economies?

The second submission says yes, and says it carefully. Smith said well-designed reward mechanisms are "the most effective way to support the transition to scalable zero-emission fuels, particularly when it comes to ensuring a fair deal for developing economies."

Reward design is where the argument usually stalls, and here the release stays quiet on mechanism specifics. No credit size, no eligibility rule, no duration. Member states reading "reward mechanisms" will each fill that gap differently, and only one of those packages is the one IMarEST tested.

What does predictability mean for owners?

The third submission is the one charterers and owners will read twice. Smith said: "Our final submission highlights the options to ensure that regulation is predictable for industry. We hope our work will help ensure investment remains focused on decarbonisation as fuel prices and technologies evolve, and as the Net Zero Framework's greenhouse gas fuel intensity limits tighten over time."

Two things move at once: fuel prices and technologies evolve, and fuel intensity limits tighten over time. Predictability, on this reading, comes with a tightening ratchet attached, which makes the direction of travel clearer than the pace of it.

Why does a global framework matter?

Alasdair Wishart, IMarEST's director of technical and policy, said: "Shipping is one of the few sectors that can tackle its emissions through a truly global regulatory framework, and a recent snapshot of our members also shows strong support for decarbonisation. That is a huge opportunity, but it will only succeed if policy gives industry the certainty needed to invest at scale."

Wishart also said: "To support this, the Institute has brought together experts from industry and academia to generate the independent evidence that IMO member states need to develop decarbonisation policy that is safe, practical and cost-effective."

The member snapshot supports decarbonisation in general, not any particular instrument. A membership survey is not a vote by IMO member states, and the release gives neither a sample size nor a date. Wishart's caveat is the operative one: certainty is the precondition for investing at scale, and certainty is exactly what member states are still negotiating.

Where MEPC 85 leaves owners

Three submissions, 60 combinations, one recommendation: keep the framework's original form, pair it with reward mechanisms and a predictable ratchet. That is usable evidence for the delegates, and it is not a decision.

The numbers a finance director wants are missing. What each pathway costs, what a zero-emission fuel earns, when the tightened limits bind: none of that appears in the release. Read the submissions as an argument, and as a signal that the Institute expects the original framework to survive largely intact. The release gives no dates or venue for MEPC 85 either, so delegates arrive with the evidence in hand and the timetable still to fix.

via Hellenic Shipping News (Source)

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Correspondent covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

30 articles

Linked entries

  1. IMO members urged to adopt Net-Zero Framework by year-end
  2. Clean Shipping Coalition Tells IMO: Adopt Net-Zero Framework As Is
  3. EU ETS likely to survive any IMO zero-carbon deal, IBIA panel says
  4. Clean Shipping Coalition Pushes for Net-Zero Framework Adoption at MEPC 85
  5. Nine Shipping Bodies Push for IMO Net-Zero Deal as Rules Split Industry

▼ Next article