Charter & Freight Markets

Mars crude flips from $17.50 premium to $4 WTI discount

Mars crude fell from a $10 WTI premium to a $4 discount in under a month, while new heavy-sour barrels left Mars uneconomical for Asian refiners and kept U.S. crude exports elevated.

Iran War Oil Premium Evaporates as Global Crude Supplies Surge
Exhibit · Iran War Oil Premium Evaporates as Global Crude Supplies Surge — generatorpowerproducts / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. Mars swung from a $10 WTI premium to a $4 discount in less than a month.
  2. Mars reached a record $17.50 WTI premium during March and April.
  3. February Mars cost Northeast Asia $12-$13 per barrel over Dubai, roughly $10 above Saudi oil.
  4. Canadian pipeline throughput hit 960,000 bpd, 8% above capacity; 34 vessels were set for November.
  5. U.S. crude exports averaged 4 million bpd over four weeks, above the 3 million bpd average since 2015.

By James Calloway

Mars crude now trades at a $4 discount to West Texas Intermediate (WTI), down from a $10 premium less than a month ago. The reversal erased the war premium that the U.S. medium-sour export grade briefly commanded as oil markets began settling after a volatile year.

The reported driver is supply. Rising production of heavy-sour crude in Venezuela and Canada, plus increased Middle Eastern flows, pushed global prices lower in recent weeks. Refiners again have ample barrels to choose from. Higher shipping costs, however, weigh on prices at the barrel’s origin and make overseas sales more expensive.

What reversed Mars’s wartime premium?

Before the U.S. and Israel launched their war in Iran in late February, Mars largely traded at a discount. Supply disruptions then pushed the grade to a record $17.50 premium to WTI futures in March and April.

Buyers turned to Gulf of Mexico crude, which resembles Middle Eastern crude in quality, when the closure of the Strait of Hormuz disrupted supplies.

That premium did not last. Mars moved from $10 above WTI to $4 below it in less than a month, its steepest discount since late September. The price drop favors U.S. refiners built for heavier crude, especially operators on the Gulf Coast and in the Midwest, as Canada and Latin America supply more heavy barrels.

Valero’s head of crude supply, Randy Hawkins, said on an October earnings call: “Incremental supply looks to be dominated by heavier and more sour barrels, especially out of Canada, Venezuela, and the Middle East.” Phillips 66’s executive vice president of marketing and commercial, Brian Mandell, described the market as a race to the bottom on an analyst call that month.

Those comments describe direction, not a price floor. Neither quantifies freight, vessel demand or the amount of new supply refiners can absorb. That leaves regional grades, shipping costs and refinery demand to split the market again.

Why doesn’t Asia buy the discount?

Mars remains uneconomical to import despite its new discount, according to traders familiar with the market who lacked authorization to speak publicly. On a delivered basis to Northeast Asia, February cargoes carried a $12 to $13 per-barrel premium to Dubai. That was roughly $10 more than similar-quality Saudi oil.

Higher flows from the Persian Gulf have also increased. Those barrels reduce the incentive for Asian refiners to switch to cheaper Mars. At least one other Middle Eastern seller has slashed offer prices, yet the delivered gap still blocks the obvious import switch.

The arithmetic matters more than the headline discount. A lower origin price can disappear inside freight and other delivery costs. Owners need the parcel terms and voyage economics before treating this reversal as higher tanker demand.

What does Canada add to tanker supply?

The pipeline moving oil-sands crude from inland fields to West Coast export markets runs at a record 960,000 barrels a day this month. That is 8% above its stated capacity.

Thirty-four vessels will load oil at Westridge terminal near Vancouver in November, up from 31 in October. The figures point to more export optionality, but they are not a complete tanker-demand forecast.

The data gives no vessel sizes, voyage lengths, loading dates or spot freight rates. It also does not link pipeline throughput directly to the vessel count. Treat them as indicators, not a one-for-one barrel-to-hull conversion.

Are refiners winning at producers’ expense?

Cheaper heavy crude is a boon for refiners already making record profits from the Iran war’s disruptions to global fuel markets. The same move hurts heavy-oil producers. “We’re basically going to have to be a price taker,” Sable Offshore Corp. chief executive Jim Flores said earlier this month. Sable pumps heavy oil off California’s coast.

U.S. crude exports of both heavy and light grades remain at historically elevated levels. Exports averaged 4 million barrels a day over the past four weeks, below the weekly record of more than 6 million set in April but well above the 3 million-barrel average since the U.S. lifted its crude-export ban in 2015.

The export figure confirms that cargo availability remains strong. It does not establish where the barrels went, how much tonnage they required or whether charter rates rose. For shipowners, the immediate cargo story is clear: cheaper heavy-sour barrels are available. The earnings story still needs freight and voyage data.

via gCaptain (Source)

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Correspondent covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

109 articles

Linked entries

  1. Brent Heads for 5% Weekly Drop as Hormuz Flows Recover
  2. Brent Heads for Third Weekly Loss as Supplies Build Despite Hormuz Risk
  3. VLCC Earnings Sink 11.5% to $270,000/Day as Hormuz Talks Stall
  4. Brent Back Above $92 as Houthi Strikes and Hormuz Mines Resurface
  5. Brent Climbs to $92.22 After Hormuz Tanker Blasts, Houthi Strike on Riyadh

▲ Previous article