Regulation & Policy

Japan’s proposal could dilute IMO’s $15bn Net-Zero Framework

The IMO’s Net-Zero Framework could raise up to $15bn a year for clean fuels. Japan’s proposed changes threaten e-fuel rewards and hand shipowners control over penalty revenue.

Will shipping get its solar moment?
Exhibit · Will shipping get its solar moment? — wal_172619 / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. The IMO’s Net-Zero Framework could generate up to $15bn annually in revenues for clean-energy investment.
  2. Shipping produces around 3% of global greenhouse-gas emissions annually.
  3. Member states agreed in 2023 to net zero by or around 2050, and a December vote is planned.
  4. Japan proposes broader “new fuels and technologies” eligibility and no dedicated e-fuel rewards.
  5. “Direct contributions” would leave shipowners largely in control of penalty revenue.

Sophie Lindqvist

Up to $15bn a year in maritime carbon-pricing revenue sits behind the IMO’s Net-Zero Framework (NZF), which member states will consider for adoption in London this December. The historic policy would drive alternative-energy uptake by combining gradually tightening carbon-intensity targets for marine fuels with carbon pricing. Owners would then choose between clean-energy investment and penalties for emissions above each threshold.

Revenue would provide additional support for clean energy, especially in low-income countries unable to afford the shipping transition alone. IMO member states agreed in 2023 that the sector should reach net zero by or around 2050, in a just and equitable way.

Yet shipping runs almost entirely on fossil fuels and produces around 3% of global greenhouse-gas emissions annually. Maersk, Cargill and other shipping giants have invested considerably in e-fuel-capable vessels. Meanwhile, new green shipping corridors link renewable-energy producers, ports and shipping companies across international markets.

When solar first entered the market, many questioned its cost and viability. Solar is now cheaper than new fossil-fuel generation, in large part because governments backed innovation and early buyers.

Jude Lee of Transport & Environment, writing for Splash, compares that policy history with shipping’s opportunity. He warns: “watering down the NZF in the name of a compromise risks sacrificing the entire clean transition in the sector.”

Why has adoption stalled?

The IMO agreed to the NZF in principle last year but failed to adopt it, leaving the regulator and industry in a costly limbo of uncertainty and delay. Energy providers have delayed investments, struggled to secure long-term offtake agreements for future fuel volumes, and continued to compete with oil and gas.

Several compromise proposals have emerged to break the deadlock. Lee says weakening the framework to secure agreement could sacrifice the wider clean-energy transition.

What would Japan change?

Japan’s proposal would significantly alter the framework. Lee identifies two changes:

  • It would weaken incentives for zero- and near-zero-emission fuels.
  • It would place companies in charge of directing investment.

The first change broadens eligibility for “new fuels and technologies.” In Lee’s assessment, that opens the door to prolonged LNG use and expanded crop-based biofuels, both of which carry substantial environmental risks.

Both fuels fall far from “near-zero,” Lee says. Their lower cost makes them more attractive in the short term, potentially locking ships into technologies that do not deliver the intended decarbonisation.

The proposal would also remove dedicated rewards for e-fuels. Producers already face high investment costs and uncertain demand, so Lee says the change adds uncertainty and favours cheap but false solutions. He calls that outcome “a recipe for dangerous technological lock-in.”

Who controls the revenue?

Japan’s “direct contributions” would decentralise the process through which ships pay penalties. Shipowners would largely control how the revenue is directed, potentially recycling it into their own supply chains and infrastructure rather than meeting wider global-sector and vulnerable-state needs.

Lee says this apparent procedural change would reduce political oversight. It would also steer payments toward immediate, short-term projects at the expense of long-term decarbonisation.

Can the IMO still deliver a solar-like transition?

The IMO faces a choice at this year’s London meeting: adopt the NZF in December or bend to short-term interests. Adoption would provide global shipping with the same policy certainty that enabled the renewable-energy boom, in Lee’s view. The alternative would weaken e-fuel incentives, prolong LNG use, expand crop-based biofuels and leave penalty revenue under shipowners’ control.

via Splash 247 (Source)

Share this article:

More from Sophie Lindqvist

Sophie Lindqvist

Show full bio

Market editor covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

37 articles

Linked entries

  1. EU ETS likely to survive any IMO zero-carbon deal, IBIA panel says
  2. Nine Shipping Bodies Push for IMO Net-Zero Deal as Rules Split Industry
  3. IMO members urged to adopt Net-Zero Framework by year-end
  4. IMO Reopens Net-Zero Framework Talks November 30
  5. Nine shipping associations seek global GHG framework at IMO’s MEPC85

▲ Previous article▼ Next article