IMO Net-Zero Framework Stalls Again as US Blocks Carbon Penalties
IMO members reconvene Nov 23–Dec 4 after failing to adopt the Net-Zero Framework in October 2025, with the US leading opposition to the carbon penalty at its core.

Adjustments
- IMO members reconvene Nov 23–Dec 4 after failing to adopt the Net-Zero Framework in October 2025
- GHG intensity thresholds tighten progressively over 2028–2035, with financial penalties for non-compliance
- Singapore October bunker costs: $22.78/GJ for VLSFO vs $48.47/GJ for 100% sustainable methanol, per Platts
- 63 countries voted to approve the framework text in April 2025; 57 voted to delay adoption in October 2025
- IBIA's Edmund Hughes says the financial mechanism remains the main obstacle to agreement
The IMO failed to adopt its Net-Zero Framework in October 2025, and the delegates flying back into session between Nov 23 and Dec 4 face the same wall that stopped them last time: the money. Washington calls the framework's financial penalties a global carbon tax on shipping, and it isn't alone.
Edmund Hughes, the International Bunker Industry Association's representative to the UN agency, told Platts on Nov 12 that regulators are struggling to craft rules that would actually compel shipping companies to follow the new bunker regulation aimed at cutting greenhouse gas emissions. His venue was the sidelines of the IBIA Annual Convention 2026.
The diagnosis is specific. "There is broad recognition of the need for a greenhouse gas intensity standard for marine fuel," Hughes said — but the financial aspects remain the main obstacle. Nobody disputes the thermometer. Everybody disputes the bill.
What does the framework actually require?
In its present form, the text sets greenhouse gas intensity thresholds for marine energy that tighten progressively over 2028–2035. Ships that miss the standard pay financial costs. That levy is the piece the United States has strongly opposed, and a growing number of member states have tabled revisions to the framework in search of a compromise.
So far, Hughes said, member states have not been able to identify the best approach.
The framework's backers designed the financial element to pull the market toward low-carbon marine fuels, which remain far more expensive than conventional oil-based product because availability is limited. The gap isn't marginal. Platts' global bunker cost calculator puts October average delivered costs in Singapore at:
- $22.78/GJ for 0.5%-sulfur fuel oil
- $27/GJ for bioblend B24
- $28.48/GJ for LNG
- $48.47/GJ for 100% sustainable methanol
Why can't the market fix this on its own?
Hughes was blunt on the economics. No shipping company would keep buying more expensive fuel while competitors do not — so some mechanism is needed to close the price gap. A levy on non-compliant fuel is one answer; he also warned that member states face real challenges designing an alternative compliance mechanism if the current net-zero framework gets rewritten.
The blocs are familiar. Most Pacific Island states and EU member states still officially back the current text. The US and Middle Eastern states remain opposed. Japan, China, Norway and some major flag states have put forward new ideas on compliance mechanisms. Hughes noted that with a technical standard, a way to comply must be found — and that multilateral discussions often involve considerable semantic maneuvering before agreement lands.
How did we get here?
The voting record tells the story. In April 2025, 63 countries approved the framework's current text by vote after the US withdrew from the negotiations. In October 2025, 57 countries voted to delay its adoption. Hughes reads those tallies as a signal: a vote already shows there is no consensus. As he put it, those who win a vote might believe they won — but in fact lost.
Consensus, he said, is the tradition member states may need to return to, coalescing around a net-zero framework so that future implementation can be ensured globally. Force majeure by ballot box doesn't install rules on 60,000 ships.
What does the bunker trade want?
IBIA describes itself as the world's largest trade association representing bunker industry participants, including traders and fuel suppliers. It holds consultative status with the IMO, and its representatives sit in on the meetings regularly. Hughes said the sector recognizes and values having global rules — they help the industry understand compliance requirements, market needs, which fuels will be supplied and what buyers actually want.
That's the quiet irony of the standoff. The people who would sell you the green fuel want the rule that forces you to buy it. The rulebook can't get past the penalty clause.
So the November 23–December 4 session opens with the same arithmetic: an agreed technical standard, an unresolved price mechanism, and a bloc of member states that won't sign a cheque. The fuel gap in Singapore runs from $22.78 to $48.47 per gigajoule. The political gap is wider.
via Google News: IMO Regulation (Source)
More from Amara Osei
Show full bio
Senior reporter covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
47 articles
Linked entries
- IMO Reopens Net-Zero Framework Talks November 30
- Nine Shipping Bodies Push for IMO Net-Zero Deal as Rules Split Industry
- Nine Shipping Bodies Demand IMO GHG Deal at MEPC 85
- Nine shipping associations seek global GHG framework at IMO’s MEPC85
- EU ETS likely to survive any IMO zero-carbon deal, IBIA panel says