Regulation & Policy

IMO Net-Zero Framework Faces Dilution Test at October Talks

MEPC 85 convenes 30 November with GHG pricing itself on the table. Japan missed the MARPOL window, the UGS accuses Brussels of sinking talks, and Greece plus three states holding 70% of the EU fleet want compromise.

IMO Net-Zero Framework Faces Compromise Test at MEPC - News and Statistics - IndexBox
Exhibit · IMO Net-Zero Framework Faces Compromise Test at MEPC - News and Statistics - IndexBox — Peter_Lindenau / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. MEPC meets 30 November–3 December; GHG working group session runs 23–27 November.
  2. Japan's proposal missed the six-month MARPOL circulation window for MEPC 85 adoption.
  3. Greece and three EU states holding 70% of the EU-controlled fleet urged a flexible EU stance.
  4. TotalEnergies scrapped its $16 billion green hydrogen-ammonia project in southern Chile.

The IMO's Marine Environment Protection Committee meets 30 November to 3 December to decide whether a diluted Net-Zero Framework can break the deadlock — or gut the transition it was built to drive.

The options on the table run from tougher economic instruments to scrapping greenhouse gas pricing entirely, ENGINE reports. In between sit the submissions stacking up for the intersessional GHG working group, set for 23-27 November.

Who is pushing what?

Liberia, Tuvalu, Brazil and a four-nation bloc of Australia, Canada, South Africa and the UK have all tabled papers for the November working group session. Japan wants gentler fuel intensity targets plus direct contributions. There's a catch: Tokyo missed the six-month MARPOL circulation window required for adoption at MEPC 85.

The EU and Pacific Island states back the text endorsed in April 2025 unchanged. The US and several others, including major oil producers, want substantial revisions to its technical and economic clauses. President Donald Trump has rejected global emissions pricing outright, saying no global government exists and no global taxes will happen while he holds office.

What does the shipping industry want?

Nine associations — BIMCO, ICS, IBIA and WSC among them — have called for an achievable, enforceable and stable regulatory framework that reflects fuel costs and availability. Their argument rests on two planks: credible transition pathways for existing ships and technologies, and regulatory certainty plus scalable, cost-competitive alternative fuels to sustain investment.

The groups also want an end to overlapping regional and international requirements, including multiple charges on the same emissions. Union of Greek Shipowners president Melina Travlos has echoed that point pointedly, asking whether the EU prizes its own regional measures, and the revenues they produce, above a global agreement.

Is the EU's rigidity the problem?

Travlos thinks so. She said the EU's rigid stance is pushing the IMO process toward another impasse, in effect sinking the negotiations by stripping them of the flexibility needed for any prospect of success. She told Brussels that Greece and three other EU member states — together accounting for 70% of the EU-controlled fleet — had urged the bloc to enter the talks genuinely willing to negotiate.

She didn't name the three. But Cyprus, Greece, Malta and Italy pushed for realistic, globally applicable and cost-effective rules at a September ministerial meeting in Limassol. All four had backed the framework's April 2025 approval and agreed to pursue the widest possible consensus on measures that foster the green fuel shift while preserving competitiveness.

Will a deal actually land?

Charles Whitfield, chairman of Australian ammonia developer NH3 Clean Energy, expects one in December — but softer than the April 2025 version. He told ENGINE he thinks "a piece of paper or an agreement will actually be ratified." He prefers a common international framework over the divergent regimes taking shape across the EU, China and Singapore.

The skeptics have research behind them. University College London's Shipping and Oceans Research Group and the Rocky Mountain Institute argue that loosening emissions targets or setting compliance payments too low could jeopardise the IMO's climate objectives and delay the shift to cleaner marine fuels.

The Clean Shipping Coalition wants the text adopted unchanged, arguing it reflects years of negotiation and that no alternative proposal has shown comparable emissions reductions or gathered enough support.

Em Fenton, senior director of climate diplomacy at Opportunity Green, warned against reopening the existing compromise. Fenton told ENGINE any major departure from the text risks damaging not only the emissions reductions achievable but also "the justice and equity of its implementation." Further delay or weakening, Fenton added, only benefits fossil fuel interests and does nothing for climate-vulnerable countries.

What stays unresolved?

Key open questions include:

  • Lifecycle emissions accounting and chain of custody
  • GHG pricing levels
  • The proposed Net-Zero Fund, meant to back cleaner technologies, infrastructure and capacity-building in vulnerable countries

A softer agreement could pull more governments in and give shipping a shared baseline. But if compliance costs less than switching fuels, that certainty may barely incentivise investment in cleaner alternatives.

Elsewhere in alt fuels

  • Lotte Fine Chemical and Höegh Autoliners plan to broaden green ammonia bunkering across South Korean ports.
  • NYK Line has revealed a newbuild gas carrier with an ammonia dual-fuel two-stroke main engine, built at Japan Marine United's Ariake Shipyard in Kumamoto Prefecture.
  • TotalEnergies has abandoned its planned $16 billion green hydrogen and ammonia project in southern Chile, citing weak demand and higher-than-expected production costs.

That last item is the tell. If a $16 billion project dies for want of demand, the framework's stringency — or lack of it — will decide whether the next one gets built.

via Google News: IMO Regulation (Source)

Share this article:

More from James Calloway

James Calloway

Show full bio

Correspondent covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

109 articles

Linked entries

  1. IMO Faces Net-Zero Framework Compromise as MEPC 85 Nears
  2. IMO to Vote on Diluted Net-Zero Framework in December
  3. IMO Reopens Net-Zero Framework Talks November 30
  4. IMO climate meetings confront shipping’s persistent emissions data gap
  5. Clean Shipping Coalition presses IMO states to adopt Net-Zero Framework in December

▲ Previous article▼ Next article