Regulation & Policy

IMO Faces Diluted Net-Zero Deal or No Deal at All

IMO member states meet from 23 November to weigh a diluted Net-Zero Framework. Greece and three EU states holding 70% of the EU-controlled fleet want Brussels to bend.

IMO Net-Zero Framework: Compromise or Weakened Climate Rules? - Global Trade Magazine
Exhibit · IMO Net-Zero Framework: Compromise or Weakened Climate Rules? - Global Trade Magazine — fietzfotos / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. GHG working group meets 23–27 November; MEPC follows 30 November–3 December
  2. Japan's proposal missed the six-month MARPOL circulation window for MEPC 85 adoption
  3. Greece plus three EU states control 70% of the EU-controlled fleet and urge flexibility
  4. Nine associations including BIMCO, ICS, IBIA and WSC demand a stable global framework
  5. TotalEnergies dropped its $16bn green hydrogen and ammonia project in southern Chile

Shipping's global climate rules hang on two weeks of talks in London, and the likeliest outcome is an agreement softer than the text member states endorsed in April 2025.

The IMO's intersessional GHG working group meets 23–27 November, followed by the Marine Environment Protection Committee from 30 November to 3 December. The agenda spans everything from tougher economic instruments to scrapping greenhouse gas pricing entirely, ENGINE reports.

The question has shifted. It's no longer whether governments can settle on a global framework, but whether the concessions needed for agreement leave shipping with rules too feeble to drive change.

Who wants what?

Submissions for the intersessional session come from Liberia, Tuvalu, Brazil, and a four-nation bloc of Australia, Canada, South Africa and the UK. Japan has tabled gentler fuel intensity targets and direct contributions — but its proposal missed the six-month MARPOL circulation window required for adoption at MEPC 85, so it arrives late by procedure as well as by ambition.

The EU and Pacific Island states want the April 2025 text adopted as endorsed. The US and several others, including major oil producers, want substantial revisions to its technical and economic clauses. President Donald Trump has publicly rejected global emissions pricing, saying no global government exists and no global taxes will occur while he holds office.

Why the compromise camp is growing

Union of Greek Shipowners president Melina Travlos said the EU's rigid stance is pushing the IMO process toward another impasse — in effect sinking the negotiations by stripping them of the flexibility any deal needs. Greece and three other EU member states, together accounting for 70% of the EU-controlled fleet, have urged Brussels to enter the talks genuinely willing to negotiate. Travlos didn't name the three, but Cyprus, Greece, Malta and Italy called for realistic, globally applicable and cost-effective rules at a September ministerial meeting in Limassol. All four backed the framework's April 2025 approval.

Nine industry associations — BIMCO, ICS, IBIA and WSC among them — want an achievable, enforceable and stable framework reflecting fuel costs and availability. They argue sustained investment hinges on global regulatory certainty plus reliable production and cost-competitive alternative fuels at scale, and they want no overlapping regional and international charges on the same emissions. Travlos has echoed the point, asking whether the EU prizes its own regional measures, and the revenues they produce, above a global agreement.

Charles Whitfield, chairman of Australian ammonia developer NH3 Clean Energy, expects a December deal, albeit softer than the April 2025 version. He told ENGINE he thinks "a piece of paper or an agreement will actually be ratified", and prefers one international framework over the diverging regimes forming across the EU, China and Singapore.

What does a weak deal cost?

Plenty, say the critics. Loosened targets or compliance payments set too low could jeopardise the IMO's climate objectives and delay the shift to cleaner fuels, according to University College College London's Shipping and Oceans Research Group and the Rocky Mountain Institute. (UCL is the source's own wording; the group is University College London's.)

The Clean Shipping Coalition wants the framework adopted unchanged, arguing the current text reflects years of negotiation and that no alternative proposal has shown comparable emissions reductions or gathered enough backing.

The proposed IMO Net-Zero Fund would back cleaner technologies, infrastructure and capacity-building, especially in vulnerable countries — support that could help least developed and developing economies through the transition.

Em Fenton, senior director of climate diplomacy at Opportunity Green, warned against reopening the existing compromise. The framework is a hard-fought multilateral deal, Fenton told ENGINE, and any major departure "risks damaging not only the emissions reductions achievable from such a regulatory measure but also the justice and equity of its implementation". Further delay or weakening, Fenton added, only benefits fossil fuel interests.

Open items include lifecycle emissions accounting, chain of custody, GHG pricing and the net-zero fund's design. A softer agreement could widen participation and give shipping a shared baseline. But if compliance costs less than switching fuels, that certainty may barely incentivise investment in cleaner alternatives.

Meanwhile, in the fuels market this week: Lotte Fine Chemical and Höegh Autoliners plan to broaden green ammonia bunkering across South Korean ports; NYK Line has shown a newbuild gas carrier with an ammonia dual-fuel two-stroke main engine, built at Japan Marine United's Ariake Shipyard in Kumamoto; and TotalEnergies has abandoned its planned $16bn green hydrogen and ammonia project in southern Chile, citing weak demand and higher-than-expected costs.

A deal in December looks likely. Whether it still moves anything is the part nobody can circulate six months in advance.

via Google News: IMO Regulation (Source)

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

125 articles

Linked entries

  1. IMO to Vote on Diluted Net-Zero Framework in December
  2. IMO Net-Zero Framework Faces Dilution Test at October Talks
  3. IMO Faces Net-Zero Framework Compromise as MEPC 85 Nears
  4. IMO Reopens Net-Zero Framework Talks November 30
  5. Nine Shipping Bodies Demand IMO GHG Deal at MEPC 85

▲ Previous article