IMO faces carbon pricing showdown after 57-49 delay vote
IMO states decide on the Net-Zero Framework from 23 November after October's 57-49 delay. NGOs warn against LNG carve-outs and weakened fuel standards in the fine print.

Adjustments
- Adoption vote stalled in October 2025 at 57 in favour, 49 against, after the framework passed overwhelmingly in April 2025
- Talks run 23 November – 4 December: ISWG-GHG-23, MEPC 85 and a possible MEPC E.2 on 4 December
- Shipping represents about 5% of global oil demand
- Over 110 maritime companies and associations back adoption this year; 30+ groups target 20% electricity in shipping energy by 2035
Shipping's first global carbon price faces its second verdict in twelve months. IMO member states will decide between 23 November and 4 December whether to adopt the Net-Zero Framework, a mechanism combining tightening carbon intensity targets with carbon pricing that was agreed by an overwhelming majority in April 2025 — then stalled in October on a 57-49 vote.
That close vote followed heavy pressure from the US, Saudi Arabia and other petro states. The IMO deferred adoption to end-2026, but a special timetable now puts the decision back in play within weeks.
What's on the schedule?
The summit runs in three parts at IMO headquarters in London:
- ISWG-GHG-23, technical working group talks, 23–27 November, focused on the framework's core elements: fossil fuel phase-out limits, clean energy and carbon pricing revenues.
- MEPC 85, the political session, 30 November – 3 December.
- MEPC E.2, a potential extraordinary session on Friday 4 December, where a final adoption vote is expected.
The outcome will govern roughly 5% of global oil demand — the share represented by international shipping. That makes the talks a stress test for energy security and climate policy at once, and a test of whether so-called middle powers can deliver a global deal without US buy-in.
Who backs it — and who's hedging?
Analysis from UCL and RMI says the framework in its current form is the most cost-effective route to the industry's commitments under the 2023 Revised Strategy. Over 110 maritime companies and associations have called on member states to adopt the NZF this year. More than 30 organizations committed at COP31 to raising electricity's share of shipping's energy use to at least 20% by 2035, arguing a strong IMO policy is a precondition.
InfluenceMap analyst Emily Zhang added a caveat the industry's own supporters should note: "We're seeing broad corporate support for the Net-Zero Framework across shipping and fuels, from major carriers to associations representing most of the world's fleet. But that support doesn't extend to every detail." Some of the same groups, she said, pushed for a lower carbon price and a weaker fuel standard, while oil and gas groups lobbied for accounting rules that "would make fossil fuels count as cleaner."
Em Fenton, Senior Director for Climate Diplomacy at Opportunity Green, put the politics bluntly: "It's crunch time and we cannot allow those who shout the loudest to pull the rug out from under the table." Member states, she said, must adopt a framework that "ensures that everyone pays a fair price for their shipping pollution."
What are the lobbyists' traps?
The sharpest warning came from T&E's Alex Springer, Deputy Director of Shipping. "The biggest danger at MEPC 85 is no longer delay, but a rushed deal designed to get Trump and his allies to the table," he said. Carving out an indefinite transition to fossil LNG and crop biofuels "would be a concession to US and Saudi business interests and will prolong shipping's fossil fuel dependency."
Equal Routes' Sandra Moguel flagged the technical fine print on methane: LNG "can look cleaner on paper than it is in practice," she said, because methane slip through engines and supply-chain leaks are easy to miss. It should not receive rewards without well-to-wake accounting of slip and leakage.
What happens if it slips again?
Delay carries its own costs, and the NGOs lined up to name them. Lucas Leppert, President of the Clean Shipping Coalition, noted that the 12-month-plus delay has coincided with floods, droughts, heatwaves and wildfires. Jesse Fahnestock, Decarbonisation Director at the Global Maritime Forum, said the space for agreement is narrowing and that weakening agreed elements risks costly delays, abandonment of first-mover investments and further regulatory fragmentation.
That fragmentation is already visible. National and regional rules are emerging in Europe and Africa, and experts warn a patchwork cannot give global trade the predictability a single IMO instrument provides.
Ocean Conservancy's Shipping Program Director, Delaine McCullough, called the agreed framework "the quickest and most effective way to protect communities, address climate change, and create certainty for the shipping industry for decades to come." Davina Hurt of Pacific Environment and Adria Jover of the International Electric Maritime Association pressed the same case — costs on polluters, funding for port-side communities, and a market signal strong enough to electrify the fleet at scale.
The claims are confident. The October vote showed the margin is eight votes, and the fine print is where lobbyists do their work.
via Hellenic Shipping News (Source)
More from James Calloway
Show full bio
Correspondent covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.
109 articles
Linked entries
- IMO Reopens Net-Zero Framework Talks November 30
- Clean Shipping Coalition Pushes for Net-Zero Framework Adoption at MEPC 85
- IMO Net-Zero Framework Faces Dilution Test at October Talks
- MEPC 85 Faces Net-Zero Showdown After Year of Deadlocked Talks
- Clean Shipping Coalition presses IMO states to adopt Net-Zero Framework in December