Regulation & Policy

Greenland's scrubber discharge ban draws fire from Clean Shipping Alliance

Greenland will ban open-loop scrubber discharges from 1 July 2027 and all EGCS discharges from 2029. CSA demands the location-specific risk assessment behind the decision be published.

Clean Shipping Alliance questions Greenland’s planned scrubber discharge ban - safety4sea
Exhibit · Clean Shipping Alliance questions Greenland’s planned scrubber discharge ban - safety4sea — LoboStudioHamburg / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. Greenland's parliament unanimously approved a phased scrubber discharge ban: open-loop from 1 July 2027, all EGCS including closed-loop and hybrid from 1 July 2029.
  2. CSA cites IMO circular MEPC.1/Circ.899 and says no location-specific risk assessment under that framework has been published.
  3. A 2021 CE Delft analysis puts MGO refining lifecycle CO₂ at +10–25% versus +1.0–1.5% for scrubber operation.
  4. Greenland's rules go beyond OSPAR's North-East Atlantic phase-out by covering territorial waters.
  5. CSA says any global ban would require amending Regulation 4 of MARPOL Annex VI through the IMO, ahead of PPR 14.

Greenland's parliament has voted unanimously to phase out scrubber wastewater discharges from 1 July 2027 — and the Clean Shipping Alliance (CSA) wants to see the science behind it before a single system gets switched off.

The Inatsisartut approved the proposal directing the government to introduce a staged ban. Open-loop scrubber discharges go first: from 1 July 2027 they will be prohibited in ports, internal waters and territorial waters. From 1 July 2029 the restriction extends to all exhaust gas cleaning systems (EGCS), including closed-loop and hybrid installations.

Andreas Chrysostomou, CSA's Executive Director, said: "If Greenland has conducted an assessment to support its planned restrictions, we urge them to publish it." He expressed disappointment with the plan while acknowledging the importance of protecting the Arctic marine environment.

What does the ruling change?

The move follows the OSPAR Commission's agreement to phase out scrubber discharges in ports and internal waters across the North-East Atlantic. Greenland goes further. Its rules reach into territorial waters, beyond what OSPAR contemplates.

Environmental groups, including the Clean Arctic Alliance, welcomed the decision and called for similar measures across the Arctic plus an eventual global prohibition through the IMO.

CSA's core objection is procedural. The organisation points to IMO circular MEPC.1/Circ.899, which sets guidelines for evaluating environmental risks of EGCS discharge — covering discharge composition, dilution, ecotoxicity and receiving-environment characteristics. In CSA's view, no assessment under that framework has demonstrated the scientific justification for Greenland's restrictions.

The group also questioned the reliance on the precautionary approach, arguing it should not replace the risk-assessment methodology in the IMO guidelines. Studies elsewhere, including a recently published peer-reviewed assessment in Puget Sound, found low or negligible environmental risk when actual operating conditions were considered — though CSA conceded risks must be judged on local conditions, not transplanted from one region to another.

Why does the IMO framework matter here?

Chrysostomou's second front is regulatory. He argued operators should be told what evidence supports each phase, with different scrubber technologies and operating modes assessed individually — the 2029 extension to closed-loop and hybrid systems gets no separate scrutiny in the current plan.

CSA pointed to Regulation 4 of MARPOL Annex VI, which recognises approved EGCS as an equivalent means of complying with sulphur limits. Calls for a global scrubber ban starting in the Arctic would require changes to international regulations, the group argued, and those changes belong in a transparent IMO process backed by location-specific science — not in separate regional restrictions tabled ahead of discussions at the IMO Sub-Committee on Pollution Prevention and Response (PPR 14).

Are scrubbers really just moving pollution to the sea?

CSA rejected that framing outright. Scrubbers remove sulphur and other substances from exhaust gases, cutting atmospheric emissions while transferring captured substances into seawater. The group also maintained EGCS reduce particulate matter, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) and metals in exhaust — with particular air-quality benefits near ports and coastal areas.

The lifecycle argument carries the numbers. Citing a 2021 CE Delft analysis, CSA said refining marine gas oil (MGO) can raise lifecycle CO₂ emissions by 10–25%, against an additional 1.0–1.5% from operating scrubbers. A 2025 well-to-wake study submitted to the IMO as PPR 13/INF.6, according to CSA, found heavy fuel oil with scrubbers could deliver equal or lower environmental impacts than VLSFO and MGO across most assessed categories.

That logic lands directly on Greenland's green-corridor ambitions. CSA questioned whether initiatives relying on MGO — including the proposed Nuuk–Reykjavík green corridor — can automatically count as environmentally preferable to continued EGCS use.

"Assessments should compare complete fuel pathways, not a visible discharge against an alternative assumed to have no impact," Chrysostomou concluded.

For operators running scrubber-equipped tonnage in North Atlantic trades, the clock is now running: two years of open-loop freedom in Greenland's territorial waters, then a full prohibition unless the IMO process — or a published Greenlandic assessment — changes the picture.

via Google News: IMO Regulation (Source)

Share this article:

More from Tom Whitfield

Tom Whitfield

Show full bio

Staff writer covering companies, deals and strategy in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

43 articles

Linked entries

  1. IMO Reopens Net-Zero Framework Talks November 30
  2. Nine Shipping Bodies Demand IMO GHG Deal at MEPC 85
  3. Nine shipping associations seek global GHG framework at IMO’s MEPC85
  4. Nine shipping bodies tell IMO: end the stalemate, give us one global rule
  5. ISO Ballot Opens on First Standard for Shipbuilding GHG Emissions

▲ Previous article