Regulation & Policy

Clean Shipping Alliance Challenges Greenland's 2027 Scrubber Ban

The Clean Shipping Alliance says Greenland's scrubber restrictions, starting 2027, lack any IMO-aligned risk assessment and urges transparent evidence before regional bans pre-empt PPR 14 talks.

Clean Shipping Alliance Questions Greenland's Scrubber Restrictions Ahead of 2027 Ban - IndexBox
Exhibit · Clean Shipping Alliance Questions Greenland's Scrubber Restrictions Ahead of 2027 Ban - IndexBox — AI-generated

Adjustments

  1. Greenland will restrict scrubbers from 2027, extending to territorial seas and adding closed-loop and hybrid systems from 2029
  2. The CSA cites MEPC.1/Circ.899 as the agreed IMO method for assessing scrubber discharge risk
  3. A CE Delft 2021 analysis found MGO refining raises lifecycle CO2 by 10-25 percent versus 1.0-1.5 percent for scrubber operation
  4. Study PPR 13/INF.6 (2025) found HFO with scrubbers delivers equal or lower impacts than VLSFO and MGO across most categories
  5. MARPOL Annex VI Regulation 4 recognises scrubbers as an equivalent means of compliance

Greenland wants scrubbers out of its waters from 2027, and the Clean Shipping Alliance wants to see the homework first. The industry group has publicly questioned what specific risk the territory has identified from exhaust gas cleaning systems and how that risk was assessed, arguing that a ban announced before any evaluation looks like regulation by assumption.

Executive Director Andreas Chrysostomou, writing for the alliance, said the group accepts the importance of protecting the Arctic's sensitive marine environment. But acceptance of the goal, he implied, is not acceptance of the method. The CSA has urged Greenland to publish whatever assessment underpins the planned restrictions.

What does the alliance actually want?

The reference point is MEPC.1/Circ.899, the IMO's agreed method for evaluating local risk from scrubber discharges. It covers the receiving environment, discharge composition, dilution and ecotoxicity. The CSA's argument runs simply: if no assessment has been conducted under those guidelines, the case for restriction has not been established through the IMO framework. A precautionary approach, the group adds, cannot replace the assessment that framework calls for.

The alliance notes that the IMO's risk characterization methods are internationally accepted and already used by many countries for licensing other discharges, so technical experts in each jurisdiction know them. Where such assessments have actually been carried out, including a recently published peer-reviewed Puget Sound study, they found low or negligible risk under real operating conditions. The CSA called that outcome unsurprising — and said announcing a restriction before assessing scrubbers in Greenland's own waters would be.

How far do the restrictions reach?

The CSA highlighted two details that operators should watch:

  • Greenland's plans extend restrictions to territorial seas, going beyond OSPAR's current recommendation.
  • Closed-loop and hybrid systems would be added from 2029.

Operators, the alliance said, are entitled to know what each phase is based on and what specific risk it addresses, with different systems and operating modes assessed on their own evidence rather than bundled together.

What about the wider regulatory fight?

The CSA characterized the call for the IMO to adopt a global ban starting in the Arctic as a bid to change international regulation. It noted that most, if not all, countries with existing scrubber restrictions have also not conducted an IMO-aligned evaluation, concluding such decisions are not based solely on recognized science.

The group pointed to Regulation 4 of MARPOL Annex VI, which recognises scrubbers as an equivalent means of compliance. Governments seeking change, it argued, should pursue a transparent amendment at the IMO supported by location-specific evidence, rather than a series of regional bans that pre-empt discussion at PPR 14.

On the familiar "pollution moved from air to sea" objection, the alliance countered that scrubbers remove sulphur and other substances from exhaust gases — cutting releases to air where they pose the greatest health risk — and discharge them to sea where they are already naturally present and quickly revert to background concentrations. Scrubbers, it added, can also significantly reduce particulate matter, PAHs and metals in exhaust emissions, particularly relevant near land, in ports and harbours included.

Is MGO the clean answer?

No, says the CSA. The same substances in scrubber discharge also appear in the air emissions of ships not using scrubbers, meaning alternatives such as the Nuuk-Reykjavik green corridor, which would rely on marine gas oil, are not impact-free. The numbers it cites:

  • A 2021 well-to-wake analysis by CE Delft found refining MGO increases lifecycle CO2 emissions by 10 to 25 percent, while operating scrubbers adds 1.0 to 1.5 percent.
  • A 2025 well-to-wake study submitted to the IMO as PPR 13/INF.6 found HFO used with scrubbers delivers equal or lower overall environmental impacts than VLSFO and MGO across most categories.

A green corridor on MGO, the alliance concluded, cannot be assumed to deliver a better overall environmental outcome than continued scrubber use, marine environment included. Assessments, it said, should compare complete fuel pathways — not a visible discharge against an alternative presumed to have no impact.

Show the assessment, then ban. In that order.

via Google News: IMO Regulation (Source)

Share this article:

More from Amara Osei

Amara Osei

Show full bio

Senior reporter covering technology and product news in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

88 articles

Linked entries

  1. Greenland's scrubber discharge ban draws fire from Clean Shipping Alliance
  2. Nine Shipping Bodies Demand IMO GHG Deal at MEPC 85
  3. Nine shipping associations seek global GHG framework at IMO’s MEPC85
  4. IMO members urged to adopt Net-Zero Framework by year-end
  5. IMO Reopens Net-Zero Framework Talks November 30

▲ Previous article