Maritime Tech

CargoWise faces four challengers ahead of contract renewals

FreightSuite, Shipthis, GoFreight and Magaya are courting CargoWise users as competition scrutiny targets switching barriers and pricing pressure builds in Europe and Australia.

CargoWise has more challengers. But how much choice do forwarders really have?
Exhibit · CargoWise has more challengers. But how much choice do forwarders really have? — Lalmch / pixabay

Adjustments

  1. CargoWise had secured rollouts with 13 of the world’s 25 largest forwarders as of 30 June, according to WiseTech Global.
  2. Magaya said EP Logistics selected it in January and Montreal-based CMS Shipping in May as CargoWise switchers.
  3. An August European Commission submission alleged no competition-law breach but sought scrutiny of switching and customs integrations.
  4. The ACCC accepted a court-enforceable divestment undertaking covering Expedient, which WiseTech acquired through e2open.
  5. Four named alternatives now target CargoWise customers: FreightSuite, Shipthis, GoFreight and Magaya.

By Rebecca Stone

WiseTech Global said it had secured rollouts for CargoWise, its global freight-forwarding operating platform, with 13 of the world’s 25 largest forwarders as of 30 June, even as four alternative platforms press customers toward switch decisions before the next contract renewal cycle.

Since WiseTech overhauled CargoWise pricing last December, some forwarders have said they had few realistic alternatives. That condition appears to be changing. FreightSuite and Shipthis now present themselves as CargoWise replacements, GoFreight is courting similar customers, and Magaya has named two forwarders that selected its software instead.

Where can rivals credibly compete?

Magaya says CargoWise has long dominated the highest enterprise tier of freight forwarding software. Its platform instead targets small and mid-market forwarders and customs brokers with integrated warehouse operations, responsive support and implementation without a six-month project or dedicated consultant.

Magaya says this distinction has long existed, but recent events at WiseTech have sharpened it and prompted forwarders to review what they pay, what they receive and which alternatives they can use.

Benjamin Riege of Germany’s Riege Software said in February: “There is really no alternative to CargoWise for the biggest global forwarders.” He added: “But when you’re a medium-sized forwarder, of course we are a choice.”

Magaya has posted two customer moves on its website. EP Logistics selected Magaya in January to replace CargoWise across its US and Mexican operations. In May, Montreal-based CMS Shipping also selected Magaya. WiseTech also named Blue Water Shipping and XPD Global as wins under its new CargoWise pricing model.

What are regulators testing?

An August submission asked the European Commission to monitor whether CargoWise’s reach and WiseTech’s acquisitions could make switching harder for forwarders, or customs-system connections less equal for rival vendors. The submission alleged no breach of competition law. The commission said it had placed the information on file.

In Australia, the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) accepted a court-enforceable undertaking (a binding divestment commitment) from WiseTech and subsidiary BluJay to divest Expedient, a logistics software business acquired through e2open. ACCC said WiseTech already held substantial market power and that common ownership of CargoWise and Expedient reduced Australian customer choice. WiseTech and BluJay disputed that assessment.

What makes multinational switching difficult?

A multinational switch must connect the replacement platform with the customs authorities, carriers and customers already served by each branch. The operational test covers three functions:

  • filing declarations from the new platform in every country where staff must submit them;
  • keeping finance teams invoicing while open jobs and unbilled charges move across; and
  • retrieving records required for an audit.

One freight-software executive said artificial intelligence (AI) may help vendors build customs integrations faster, but “the actual government sign-off is always going to be the bottleneck.”

The same executive expects the system of record (the authoritative business record) to remain the owner of AI and the operating process. That logic also supports AI vendors taking on the core platform itself.

Where does renewal leverage lead?

The next CargoWise renewal may be where forwarders first feel the benefit of more competition, with credible alternatives giving them more room to negotiate on price and support even if they stay.

via The Loadstar (Source)

Share this article:

More from Rebecca Stone

Rebecca Stone

Show full bio

News editor covering people, launches and day-to-day practice in commercial shipping for industry professionals at Vessels.

59 articles

Linked entries

  1. Omni-shoring pushes freight risk toward secondary gateways
  2. Nodal Networks banks $11.3M seed for AI terminal ops platform Malcom
  3. Steer acquires Mercator consultancy in fourth deal since 2021
  4. Steer acquires Mercator to expand North American port advisory
  5. Boluda agrees Samskip deal, targeting 32-vessel short-sea network

▲ Previous article▼ Next article